Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Symptoms
Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Symptoms
A hip fracture is one of the few injuries where the symptoms are usually unmistakable and the diagnosis is still missed, because the fracture can be walked on. Pain in the groin after a fall, an inability to take weight on the leg, and a leg that looks shorter and turned outwards describe most hip fractures. What makes the condition worth understanding is the exception: an undisplaced fracture can hurt only mildly, and the person may still be walking.
How it starts — the fall, and the fall that was not the cause
Most hip fractures happen in a way that is easy to picture. An older person trips on a rug, a step or a kerb, falls onto the side of the hip, and cannot get up. Falls from standing height cause the great majority, and it does not take a heavy impact: the bone fails at the moment of landing, in force that a younger skeleton would absorb without consequence.
Two variations change what should happen next. The first is the spontaneous fracture. In badly weakened bone, the thigh bone can give way while the person is turning, stepping down a kerb or simply standing up, and the fall that follows is the result rather than the cause. Patients describe it the other way round — that they fell and then could not get up — but the sequence is that the bone broke first and the leg folded underneath them. The second is the fracture that follows no fall at all, where a patient with severe osteoporosis notices a sharp deep pain in the groin and then finds the leg will not carry them. There is no bruise, no remembered injury and no obvious explanation, and this is exactly the situation in which a fracture is dismissed as a strain.
Timing is the other part of the story. Hip fractures are usually sudden: there is a moment before and a moment after, and the pain begins immediately. A dull ache in the hip that has been present for months, without any injury and without any moment of change, is much more likely to be an arthritic joint. The exception is the stress injury in a young athlete, which builds up over weeks and is described on the causes page.
The pain it produces, and where you feel it
A hip fracture hurts in the groin and the upper thigh, and this is the detail patients most often get wrong when they describe it. It is natural to expect the pain of a broken hip to sit over the outer part of the hip, where the bony prominence can be felt. In fact pain from the hip joint is felt in front, in the crease of the groin, and it can travel down the front of the thigh towards the knee. Some patients have no hip pain at all and present with pain in the knee, which is why a hip fracture is one of the classic causes of a knee that is treated for weeks with nothing to show for it.
What the pain responds to is almost diagnostic. It is at its worst when the hip is moved — turning over in bed, lifting the leg, getting out of a low chair — and it eases when the leg is left completely still and supported, flat, with the knee slightly bent. That pattern differs from the pain of a worn joint, which is worse with walking and better with sitting, and from the pain of an inflamed tendon, which is felt on the outer side of the hip and eases as the muscles warm up.
There is one examination finding worth knowing by name, because a doctor will use it. Rolling the leg gently from side to side with the patient flat and relaxed is called the log roll. In a hip fracture it produces pain deep in the groin even though the leg moves only a few degrees. It is one of the most reliable signs there is, and it can be positive when the radiograph is normal and the patient is still walking. An inability to lift the straight leg off the bed against light resistance points the same way. Severity of pain, on the other hand, is a poor guide: pain may ease over the first hours if the fragments are impacted, and a patient who feels a little better by the evening may reasonably conclude that nothing is broken.
Can you still walk? The single most useful question
If one question had to be chosen to sort a painful hip after a fall, it would be this one: will the leg take weight? It is more useful than the amount of pain, more useful than the appearance of the leg, and more useful than the radiograph on its own.
In a displaced fracture — the fragments have moved out of line — the answer is almost always no. Standing is impossible, and an attempt produces severe pain and often a sensation of the leg giving way. In an undisplaced or impacted fracture the answer can be yes. The bone is cracked but the fragments have not separated, the broken surfaces are still pressed together, and the leg can carry weight with a limp and a deep ache in the groin. People in this situation walk into the emergency department, and the fracture is missed unless somebody thinks about it.
Two consequences follow, and they are the practical heart of this page. The first is that being able to walk does not exclude a hip fracture. It excludes a fully displaced one, which is the type that needs urgent surgery most obviously, and tells you nothing about the others. The second is that an undisplaced fracture can displace if it is walked on. The bone is already cracked through; the fragments are held in line by their own edges and by the fibrous attachments that are still intact, and those can give way with the next misjudged step. A fracture that could have been pinned through three small incisions becomes one that needs a replacement.
The reverse error is also real. Not everybody who cannot walk after a fall has broken the hip: a painful bruise, a muscle strain, a fracture of the pelvis rather than the thigh bone, and severe knee arthritis can all make a person unwilling to walk. That is not a reason to wait at home — it is a reason to be assessed.
The shortened, turned-out leg — and why many fractures have no deformity
In a displaced hip fracture the leg on the injured side is shorter than the other one and lies turned outwards, with the foot pointing away to the side. The reason is mechanical: when the head of the bone has come off the neck, the pull of the muscles around the hip shortens the leg, and the same muscles rotate it outwards.
Because that sign is memorable, it is easy to over-rely on it, and that is a mistake in both directions. An undisplaced or impacted fracture has no deformity at all — the fragments are still in line, the leg lengths are equal, and the foot points the way it always did. The most commonly missed hip fractures are precisely the ones with a normal-looking leg. In the other direction, a leg that is turned outwards is not by itself proof of a fracture: patients with a long-standing stiff hip, or with arthritis that has developed a fixed outward twist, can lie with the foot turned out without any injury having occurred.
The limb needs to be looked at rather than judged. A clinician will compare the two legs for length, look at the resting position of the foot, and examine the hip gently. What is not useful — and what should never be done to an unoperated hip fracture — is trying to straighten the leg, testing its range of movement by force, or encouraging the patient to walk to see whether they can. That is how an undisplaced fracture becomes a displaced one.
The ordinary things it usually turns out to be
Most painful hips after a fall do not contain a hip fracture, and naming the alternatives explains why the assessment is ordered the way it is.
- A bruise or soft-tissue injury over the outer hip. A direct knock produces a tender swelling that hurts when the person lies on it, while the joint itself moves comfortably and weight-bearing is possible. There is no groin pain and the log roll is comfortable.
- A strain of the muscles around the hip. Pain comes on with activity, is felt in the buttock or outer thigh rather than the groin, and improves as the muscles warm up.
- A fracture of the pelvis rather than the thigh bone. A break of the pubic ramus is common after a fall in an older person, hurts in the groin, and is often treated without an operation. The two look similar and are managed differently, which is why the whole pelvis is imaged rather than the hip alone.
- A worn or inflamed hip joint. Arthritis causes groin pain that is worse on walking and easier with rest, over months rather than seconds, with a stiffness that builds up gradually.
- Pain referred from the back. A narrowed spinal canal or a trapped nerve can produce pain running down the front of the thigh, and it is a common source of confusion because the hip itself moves freely. Our guides to lumbar canal narrowing and a slipped lumbar disc cover those separately.
- An infection in the joint, or a bone weakened by something else. Both are uncommon, both produce pain that does not fit the pattern described here, and both are why an unusual presentation is imaged thoroughly rather than treated as a strain.
The list is not a checklist for self-diagnosis, because these conditions are told apart by examination and imaging rather than by how they feel. It explains why everybody who cannot take weight on the leg after a fall is investigated: most of them will not have a hip fracture, and the ones who do need to be found quickly.
When it is an emergency, and when it is a same-day appointment
There are two situations here, and they are worth keeping separate.
Call for emergency help and do not move the patient to a car if somebody who has fallen cannot get up, cannot put weight on the leg, or has a leg that looks short and turned outwards. Leave them where they are, keep them warm, support the leg in the position it has adopted — a pillow under the knee is usually enough — and wait for the ambulance. Do not try to stand them up to see whether they can manage, do not straighten the leg, and do not lift them yourself. An unoperated hip fracture is unstable, and the moving and lifting is the part that makes it worse.
Seek assessment the same day, not an appointment next week if somebody has fallen and is now walking with a limp and a deep ache in the groin; if the hip still hurts when turning in bed two or three days after a fall; or if there is any groin or thigh pain after a fall in somebody with known osteoporosis, however mild it seems. Walking is not proof that the fracture is absent — it is the reason this group is missed.
| What is happening | What it may mean | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| A fall, then unable to get up or take weight on the leg | A displaced hip fracture is likely | Call emergency services; do not move or try to walk on the leg |
| A leg that is shorter than the other and turned outwards | A displaced hip fracture | Emergency assessment; keep the leg supported in the position it has taken |
| Groin pain on turning in bed, days after a fall, but still able to walk | An undisplaced fracture cannot be excluded | Same-day assessment; ask specifically for the hip to be imaged |
| Groin or thigh pain after a fall in someone with osteoporosis | A fragility fracture of the hip must be excluded | Same-day assessment rather than waiting for symptoms to worsen |
| Pain over the outer hip that hurts when lying on it, joint moving freely | Usually a bruise or a tendon problem | An early appointment; the joint still needs examining |
One rule covers all of this. In an older person, a fall followed by any hip pain is a reason to be seen the same day. Hip fractures are not dangerous because the bone is broken — they are dangerous because the patient cannot move, and everything that follows from being unable to move starts on the first day. Being assessed and sent home with a normal radiograph and a clear plan is a good outcome. Being left at home because the pain seemed manageable is not.