FOSUN HEALTH Logo

Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Causes

catalogue

Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Causes

Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Causes

A hip fracture happens when a fall meets a bone that has lost strength, and both halves of that sentence matter. The fall supplies the force; the bone decides whether the force is survivable. In an older adult the bone has usually been thinning for years without any symptom, sometimes because of steroids or another illness, while the fall may be caused by a medicine, poor balance or something in the home. In a younger person the same fracture usually needs a much bigger injury.

The fall: what happens at the moment of the fracture

Almost every hip fracture in an older adult begins with a fall from standing height or less — a trip on a step, a slip on a wet floor, a stumble on the way to the bathroom at night. The mechanics explain why this particular bone breaks so readily and why the same fall does not break the hip of a younger person.

Two things conspire at the moment of landing. The first is direction: falling sideways onto the hip delivers the force along the line of the neck, which is the direction in which this bone is least able to resist it. A fall forwards onto the hands and knees transmits force differently, which is one reason some falls cause a wrist fracture and others cause a hip fracture. The protective reflexes that make a younger person put an arm out are also slower or absent in a frail older person, so the hip takes the impact directly.

The second is the bone itself, and this is the part most often missed. Walkers and runners who fall on the hip rarely break it. Elderly patients with thin bone break it in falls they would describe as unremarkable — a slip off a low step, a stumble on flat pavement, a slide out of a chair. When the fall seems too trivial to explain the injury, the explanation is usually not that the fall was worse than it appeared but that the bone was weaker than anyone had realised.

There is also a group in whom the sequence runs the other way: the bone breaks first, during an ordinary movement, and the fall follows because the leg will not hold. The detail that gives it away is that the pain began before the fall, or that there was no obstacle to trip on. Finally, a fall is worth separating from its cause. Balance, vision, blood pressure, footwear, medicines and the floor of the bathroom all contribute, and each is somewhere something can be changed.

The bone was almost always already weakened

In an older adult, a hip fracture is very often the first event that reveals osteoporosis. The condition produces no symptoms until a bone breaks. It is a loss of both the amount of bone and the quality of the structure inside it: the fine lattice of struts that gives bone its strength becomes thinner and more disconnected, so the bone can look fairly solid on a radiograph and still fail under a load it would once have carried easily.

Two consequences follow. The first is that a hip fracture in an older person is not just an injury — it is a diagnosis about the whole skeleton, and the spine, the other hip and the wrist are all at the same risk. That is why treating the bone is part of treating the fracture rather than an optional extra. The second is that the weakening usually cannot be felt. A patient who says they have always had strong bones, because they never broke one, has no more information about their density than a patient who has never had their blood pressure measured has about their blood pressure.

The loss of bone with age is a normal process that runs faster in some people than others, and faster still in the presence of the medicines and conditions described below. Small bones lose strength earlier than large ones, which is one reason a small, thin frame is a risk factor in its own right, and why a low body weight appears repeatedly in the list. It is worth adding that the bone does not break because the impact was large. In a fragility fracture the injury is, by definition, no more than a fall from standing height or less.

Age and sex: how the risk changes over a lifetime

The two strongest influences on the risk of a hip fracture are age and sex, and neither can be changed. Understanding why they matter explains the logic behind who is offered tests and treatment.

Age works through both halves of the mechanism at once. Bone density falls with increasing age in everybody, and at the same time the reflexes that break a fall, the muscle strength that steadies a stumble and the balance that prevents it all degrade. Vision changes, hearing changes, reaction times lengthen. So the chance of falling rises at the same time that the bone becomes less able to survive a fall, and the two curves multiply rather than add. That is why the risk rises steeply only in the later decades of life rather than steadily through adulthood.

Sex matters because bone loss accelerates after the menopause. Women lose bone faster than men around and after the change of life, and reach a lower density at any given age, which is why hip fractures are more common in women. The consequence worth noticing is that men are often under-investigated: a man who fractures a hip in a fall from standing height has the same message about his skeleton as a woman does. The conditions that cause bone loss in men — low testosterone, long-term steroid treatment, alcohol taken above the recommended limit — are looked for specifically in that group. Neither factor is a reason to be fatalistic: age is unchangeable, but the bone and the risk of falling are not.

Medicines that weaken bone, and medicines that cause falls

The medicine cabinet contributes to hip fractures in two quite different ways, and patients are often surprised by both.

The first group acts on the bone. Glucocorticoids — steroid tablets taken for asthma, arthritis, inflammatory bowel disease and many other conditions — are the most important. They reduce bone density steadily while they are taken and, separately, make fractures more likely at any given density, so the weakening is not fully captured by a density measurement. Other drugs are associated with bone loss over long periods, including some taken for stomach acidity and some used for mood or seizures; the effect is smaller, but the number of people taking them is large, so they belong in the review.

The second group acts on the risk of falling, a different route to the same fracture. Sedatives and sleeping tablets reduce alertness and slow the reactions that turn a stumble into a recovery. Antidepressants of several classes are associated with falls in older people. Blood-pressure medicines and drugs for an enlarged prostate can cause a drop in pressure on standing, so that the patient feels light-headed for a few steps after getting up — and those few steps are when many falls happen. Painkillers of the opioid type, often given for chronic pain, affect alertness and balance. Anticoagulants do not cause fractures, but they matter greatly once one has happened, because they have to be considered before the operation.

The right response is not to stop medicines without advice — several are doing important work, and stopping them abruptly can be more dangerous than the fall risk they carry. The right response is a medication review: going through the whole list with a doctor or pharmacist, asking for each drug whether it is still needed, whether the dose is the lowest that works, and whether there is an alternative with less effect on balance or on bone. This is one of the most productive things that can be done after a hip fracture.

Medical conditions that raise the risk

A number of conditions increase the chance of a hip fracture, some by weakening the bone and others by making a fall more likely. They matter because most can be identified and, in part, treated.

  • Conditions that affect balance and walking. Parkinson disease, a previous stroke, nerve damage in the feet from diabetes, and inner-ear problems all make falls more likely and reduce the ability to recover from a stumble.
  • Conditions that affect vision. Cataracts, glaucoma and degeneration of the central retina make the hazards of a room harder to see, particularly in dim light at night.
  • Loss of memory and thinking. A decline in memory raises the risk, both because the hazard is less well recognised and because the response to a stumble is slower. It also means a fracture may be sustained and not reported.
  • Conditions that weaken bone directly. An overactive thyroid or parathyroid gland, long-standing kidney disease, poor absorption of nutrients from the gut, and a group of hormonal conditions including low testosterone in men all take bone away.
  • Diabetes. Both types are associated with a higher fracture risk, through the nerve damage that affects balance in some patients and through an effect on bone quality.
  • Inflammatory conditions. Rheumatoid arthritis and similar diseases raise the risk both through the condition and through the steroid treatment often used for it.
  • Earlier fractures. A previous fracture of the hip, spine, wrist or upper arm is among the strongest warnings of a further one, whatever the bone density result says.
  • Frailty and dependence. Needing help with everyday activities, a recent hospital admission, and living with less supervision are all associated with a higher risk.

The value of the list is that it reframes the fracture as a symptom of something that can be investigated. A patient who breaks a hip after a fall from standing height, who also takes a steroid or has an untreated thyroid problem, has two or three separate opportunities to reduce the risk of the next fracture — and finding them is part of the assessment.

Smoking, alcohol, weight, diet and activity

The everyday factors matter, and they matter in both halves of the mechanism.

Smoking reduces bone density and slows healing, and it is one of the few risk factors that can be removed entirely. Alcohol taken above the recommended limit acts in three ways: it reduces bone density, it increases the risk of falling, and falls under its influence are frequently unwitnessed and more likely to be repeated.

Low body weight and a small frame are consistently associated with a higher risk, for two reasons. Less body mass means less bone to lose, since the skeleton builds itself partly in response to the loads it carries. And in a thin person there is less soft tissue around the hip to absorb the impact of a fall. It follows that unintentional weight loss in an older person is worth investigating rather than celebrating.

Diet supplies the raw materials. Calcium intake below what the body needs is common, and vitamin D deficiency is extremely common in older people and in those who spend little time outdoors; both are treatable and both are measured routinely when a fragility fracture has occurred. Protein is the part most often overlooked: muscle is the scaffolding that keeps a person upright, and a diet short of protein contributes to the weakness that leads to a fall.

Activity is protective in a way that surprises people, because exercise works on both halves at once. Weight-bearing and resistance exercise preserve bone density, and the same exercise builds the leg strength and balance that prevent falls. The point is not to start running at seventy; it is that a walk, some stairs and some resistance work are worth more than the sum of their parts. Being inactive is itself a risk factor.

Unusual mechanisms: the stress fracture and the atypical fracture

Most of this page has been about older patients with weakened bone, but two other mechanisms produce fractures in the same part of the body and are treated differently.

A stress fracture of the neck of the thigh bone occurs in active younger people, typically runners, dancers and military recruits who increase the volume of their training faster than the bone can adapt. It does not follow a fall. The pain is an ache in the groin that comes on with activity, eases with rest, and gradually begins to be present during ordinary walking. The reason it matters is that a stress injury allowed to progress can complete into a displaced fracture, which is a much more serious injury in a young person than the same fracture in an older one. Any unexplained groin pain in a young athlete that persists despite rest deserves an image.

An atypical femoral fracture is a rarer pattern occurring in a small number of patients who have taken drugs for osteoporosis for several years, most often one of the bisphosphonate group. It is a low-energy fracture of the thigh bone with a characteristic appearance that a surgeon trained in this area will recognise. The situation is subtle: these drugs substantially reduce the risk of the common fractures and are the right treatment for most people who take them. In a very small number of long-term users an unusual fracture pattern can appear, and the useful thing about knowing it exists is that it explains why a patient on treatment for several years who develops a new thigh pain is imaged rather than told that the drug has made a fracture impossible.

A third mechanism belongs on the list as well, though it is not a disease of bone: a fracture through a part of the bone weakened by a tumour or an infection. It produces a break after an injury that seems too minor, in a place where a break would not be expected, sometimes with pain that preceded the injury. It is uncommon, and it is the reason an unexplained fracture in an older person is imaged thoroughly rather than assumed to be osteoporosis.

Four things that are commonly believed and are wrong

It only happens to very old people. It becomes much more common with age, but it is not confined to the very old, and it happens to people in their sixties and to younger patients with a specific cause for bone loss — long-term steroid treatment, an overactive parathyroid, an eating disorder, or a period of immobility. The mistake this belief causes is that a fracture in a 62-year-old is not investigated, when it should be.

I have strong bones, I have never broken anything. Osteoporosis causes no symptoms before a fracture, and most people who have it do not know. The absence of previous fractures is not evidence of strong bone, any more than the absence of chest pain is evidence of a healthy heart. The only way to know is to be measured.

It was a bad fall that did it. A fall from standing height is the definition of a low-energy injury, and it is exactly the mechanism by which a hip fracture happens when bone is weak. A patient who describes the fall as unremarkable, or who cannot explain it at all, is describing a fragility fracture rather than an accident. This matters because believing that the fall was the cause, and the bone was fine, is the belief that stops the bone from being treated.

Calcium is enough. Calcium and vitamin D are necessary and neither is sufficient. Where the bone density is low enough to warrant it, a drug treatment that changes the balance of bone turnover is what reduces the risk, and calcium alone does not. Equally, taking a drug without correcting a vitamin D deficiency or reviewing the medicines that cause falls leaves part of the problem untouched.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a hip fracture mean I have osteoporosis?

It means the question has to be asked and answered, and often the answer is yes. In an older adult, a hip fracture after a fall from standing height or less is a fragility fracture by definition, and a fragility fracture is the clearest signal that the skeleton has lost strength. It does not follow that the cause is always simple, which is why the assessment includes a measurement of bone density and blood tests for vitamin D, calcium, parathyroid and thyroid function, as well as a review of medicines such as steroids that damage bone. In a younger patient with a hip fracture after a major injury the bone may be entirely normal, and the tests are directed differently.

I have never fallen before — why did I fall this time?

A first fall late in life is usually not random, and finding the reason is part of preventing the next one. The common contributors are a drop in blood pressure on standing, which often follows a change in blood-pressure medicine; a new sedative, sleeping tablet or painkiller; reduced vision that has not been reviewed; a change in balance from an inner-ear problem or nerve damage in the feet; a foot problem or unsuitable footwear; and a hazard in the home that had been managed for years until the day it was not. All of these can be examined, and most of them can be changed.

Can taking medicine for osteoporosis cause a fracture?

One group of medicines, taken for several years, is associated with a rare and unusual fracture of the thigh bone called an atypical femoral fracture, and it is right that patients on long-term treatment should know this. What matters more is the size of the two effects. These drugs substantially reduce the risk of the common fractures — including the hip fracture we are discussing — in people whose bone density is low enough to warrant treatment, and the unusual fracture is a rare pattern in a small minority of long-term users. The answer is not to avoid treatment but to take it under review, and to investigate any new pain in the thigh rather than assuming it is muscular.

Is it true that a hip fracture runs in families?

There is a real inherited component to both bone density and the tendency to fracture, and a family history of a hip fracture in a parent is one of the factors that raises the risk in the person concerned. It is a long way from being a destiny. Bone density at any age is the product of inheritance, the years of nutrition that built the skeleton, hormone changes after the menopause, medicines, medical conditions and activity — and only some of those are fixed. A family history is a reason to be measured earlier and reviewed more carefully rather than a reason to expect a fracture.

Send the records, not only the summary

Upload the radiographs and any imaging of the hip, the bone density result if you have one, the blood results including vitamin D, calcium and thyroid function, and a complete list of current medicines with doses. A short note about how many falls there have been, and what the patient was taking at the time of the fracture, helps more than a long medical history. Our team will set out what the fracture says about the bone, which of the treatable causes appear to be present, and what the assessment should include.

Want to see the whole process first? Your full medical journey, step by step →

Book an Appointment Request a Video Consultation

WhatsApp +86 172-7459-8280 · EN / 中文 · 24h within business hours

Follow Fosun Health

Apply for an Appointment

Do you have test results*