Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Diagnosis
Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Diagnosis
Confirming a hip fracture usually takes two radiographs: one of the whole pelvis, so the injured side can be compared with the other, and one taken from the side, which shows the neck of the bone end-on. Together they show where the break is and how far the fragments have moved, which is what plans the operation. When the film looks normal but the hip is painful and will not take weight, the fracture is treated as present until proved otherwise, and an MRI or a CT is arranged. The tests that follow are not to make the diagnosis but to make the operation safe.
The first two films, and why both of them are taken
Imaging a suspected hip fracture begins with two plain radiographs, and the routine is fixed for good reason. The first is an anteroposterior film of the whole pelvis, taken with both hips on the same image. The second is a lateral film of the injured hip, taken with the beam directed across the hip from the side.
The pelvis film earns its place by showing both sides at once. The two hips of a healthy person are remarkably symmetrical: the angle between the neck of the bone and its shaft, the length of the neck, and the smooth S-shaped curve traced by the inner edge of the neck as it meets the socket — the line that generations of surgeons were taught to call Shenton line — all have a mirror image on the other side. Comparing the injured hip with the normal one turns a subtle difference into an obvious one, and subtle differences are exactly what an undisplaced fracture produces. A lateral film of the one hip cannot do this, because there is nothing to compare it with.
The lateral film earns its place differently, by showing the neck end-on. On the anteroposterior view the neck is seen from the front, and a fracture that has only tilted forwards or backwards can be hidden by the overlapping bone of the head and the trochanters. Viewed from the side, that tilt becomes a visible step in the line of the neck and a clear gap between the fragments. It also shows the position of the head within the socket, which is what tells the surgeon how far the fragments have displaced.
What the surgeon reads off the two images is a short, fixed list, and it is worth knowing what is on it because it is the same list every time. Which of the three zones the break passes through. How far the fragments have separated, and therefore the Garden grade if it is a neck fracture. Whether the bone has broken into several pieces, and whether the direction of the break is one that a screw will hold. Whether the outer wall of the trochanteric block is intact. And whether anything else has broken — a second fracture in the pelvis, or another level of the same bone — because a hip fracture is not always alone.
What a plain radiograph cannot show
Plain films are quick, cheap, available at any hour and remarkably informative. They also have three blind spots, and knowing them is more useful than trusting the film without qualification.
The first blind spot is the undisplaced fracture. A crack that has not opened, with the fragments still pressed together, may not disturb the outline of the bone enough to be seen, particularly in bone that is thin from osteoporosis and in a patient who is uncomfortable enough to make positioning difficult. This is not a rare technical failure; it is a recognised limitation of the test, and it is why the clinical findings carry so much weight in this particular injury.
The second blind spot is the blood supply to the ball of the joint. Whether the head of the thigh bone still has a living blood supply cannot be seen on any radiograph. There is no shadow that represents perfusion, and the early changes of bone death appear only months later. This is the reason a displaced fracture in an older patient is often replaced rather than pinned — not because the imaging has shown the bone to be dead, but because the imaging cannot show that it is alive, and the odds are understood to be against it. Catching it later, with follow-up imaging, is the strategy for the fractures that are pinned.
The third blind spot is bone quality. A radiograph can suggest that bone looks thin, but it cannot measure density, and it says nothing about the conditions that weaken bone from within. That is a separate assessment, and it is described below.
There is one further limitation that has nothing to do with the image and everything to do with the reader. A hip fracture that is visible in retrospect is sometimes not seen on the first pass, particularly when the film is read in a busy emergency department by somebody who is not looking for a subtle one. The practical defence against this is the clinical examination: a patient who cannot take weight on the leg, or who has groin pain when the leg is rolled gently from side to side, has a fracture until imaging has proved otherwise, whatever the initial report says.
The normal radiograph: finding the fracture that has been missed
This is the situation that matters most on this page, because it is the one where a hip fracture can be lost. The patient has fallen, the hip hurts, the leg will not take weight — and the radiographs are reported as showing no fracture. There are then two possibilities, and they look identical from the outside: there is no fracture, or there is one that the film has not shown.
Three findings push the balance towards the second. The first is an inability to take weight on the leg at all, rather than a reluctance to do so because it hurts. The second is pain in the groin when the leg is rolled passively from side to side with the patient relaxed, which puts no load through the bone but does move the hip. The third is an inability to lift the straight leg off the bed against light resistance, which requires the hip to be loaded through its own muscles. Any of these, in a patient who has fallen, is treated as evidence of a fracture that the film has not shown.
The response is a cross-sectional image rather than a repeat radiograph. MRI is the most sensitive test: a fracture disturbs the marrow inside the bone, and MRI shows that disturbance as a line of altered signal running through the neck, visible long before the bone outline changes. Where MRI is not available or cannot be performed — some patients cannot lie still enough, or have an implant that is not safe in the scanner — CT is the alternative, and it will show most undisplaced fractures, though not quite as reliably as MRI.
The option that should be resisted is sending the patient home to see whether the pain settles, with a plan to repeat the radiograph in a week or two. That is safe for some injuries and not for this one. The fragments in an undisplaced fracture are held in line by their own edges and by the soft tissues around the hip; walking on them applies a twisting load that can separate them, and a fracture that displaces may need an operation that was not necessary before. A week of uncertainty is a week of not being allowed to walk, and immobility in an older patient carries its own cost. The safest path, when the findings point to a fracture that the film has not shown, is to establish the answer now.
CT and MRI: which question each one answers
The two cross-sectional tests are not interchangeable, and the difference is worth stating plainly because patients often arrive having had one of them and assuming the other questions have been answered too.
CT is a map of the bone. It shows the fracture in three dimensions, and it is the test that answers the question a surgeon needs answered — how the bone has broken: how far the break runs, whether there are several fragments, whether the outer wall of the trochanteric block is intact, and whether the line carries on below the trochanters into the shaft. Those details choose the implant, and where the pattern is complicated the operation is planned on the CT before the patient reaches the theatre. Its weakness is the opposite of its strength: it is a picture of mineral, so the earliest bruising inside the marrow of a non-displaced fracture may not show, and it says nothing about blood supply.
MRI is a map of the tissue inside the bone. It shows marrow bruising where the bone has fractured, which is why it finds fractures that plain films have missed, and it shows the state of the head of the bone over time. Its weaknesses are practical rather than diagnostic: it takes longer, it is not available in every hospital at every hour, and it depends on the patient being able to lie still and comfortably enough to produce a usable image. A patient with an unoperated hip fracture is not always able to do that, which is one reason CT is often the more realistic test in the acute setting.
Neither test replaces the plain films, and neither is needed for the obvious case. A patient with a displaced fracture on a good radiograph needs no further diagnosis at all: the film is enough, and the priorities are pain control, medical assessment, and getting to the operating theatre. Cross-sectional imaging is for the cases where a question remains open — the fracture that may have been missed, the pattern that must be understood before an implant is chosen, and the follow-up of a fracture that has been pinned.
The tests that look at the bone rather than the fracture
A hip fracture in an older adult is two problems occupying the same patient. One is the break in the bone, which is dealt with by an operation. The other is the condition of the skeleton that allowed the break to happen at a force that should not have caused it, and that is dealt with by tests and treatment rather than by surgery. The assessment belongs in the same admission, not in a clinic appointment months later that many patients never attend.
Measuring bone density is the central test, usually by a scan of the hip and the spine that uses a very small dose of radiation. It gives a number that describes how much bone is there, and it is useful for decisions about treatment and for tracking the response to it. It is worth being clear about what the number does not do: it does not diagnose the fracture, it does not explain the pain, and it does not predict what will happen to this particular patient. A density result describes the skeleton, not the injury.
Blood tests then look for the causes of bone loss that can be corrected. Low vitamin D is common and is treated directly. Disturbance of calcium, parathyroid and thyroid function are searched for specifically, because each has its own treatment and each will continue to damage bone until it is found. Markers of bone turnover give a picture of how fast bone is being broken down and rebuilt. Alongside these, a set of tests looks for the conditions that affect bone indirectly — kidney disease, problems with absorption from the gut, and a group of hormonal and inflammatory conditions that are easy to overlook.
Medicines are reviewed as part of the same assessment rather than as an afterthought, because several of the drugs an older patient is likely to be taking act on bone or on the risk of falling. Steroid treatment weakens bone at any density. Drugs given for stomach symptoms are associated with bone loss when used for years. Sedatives, sleeping tablets and some blood-pressure medicines increase the chance of a fall, and a fall is the other half of the mechanism by which the bone was broken. A full list of everything the patient takes, however trivial it seems, is part of the assessment.
From the emergency department to a plan
The sequence from arrival to an operation is short by design, and knowing it makes the experience less confusing, particularly for a patient who has been brought in by ambulance and is in pain.
The fracture is confirmed and described: which zone, how much displacement, which pattern, and whether anything else has broken. Pain is brought under control, which usually means an injection of a strong painkiller rather than tablets, and the leg is supported in a comfortable position. A medical assessment follows immediately, covering heart and lung function, kidney function, blood counts, the electrocardiogram and a review of every medicine, because the purpose of all of it is to establish whether the patient is ready for an anaesthetic and, if not, what would make them ready.
In parallel, the practical side is arranged. The patient is kept warm, which matters more than it sounds — being cold makes bleeding and heart strain more likely. Pressure areas are protected. Blood thinners are considered, since immobility is a risk for clots in the legs. Fluids are given. Nutrition is looked at, because many patients who break a hip arrive already undernourished. And the memory and thinking of the patient are assessed at the outset, so that confusion which develops later can be recognised as a change rather than mistaken for the state the patient was in before.
The plan that comes out of all this has four parts, and a patient or family can reasonably ask for each of them by name. What the operation will be, and why that one rather than the alternatives. When it will happen, and what — if anything — is being waited for. What the patient will be expected to do afterwards, particularly how soon they will sit out and take weight. And what will be done about the bone itself, including the treatment for osteoporosis and the assessment of the risk of falling, so that the second fracture is the one that gets prevented.