Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Prevention
Femoral Neck & Hip Fracture Prevention
Preventing a hip fracture means working on two things at once: the strength of the bone and the chance of falling. The bone is improved with calcium, vitamin D, adequate protein, measured exercise and, where the density is low enough, drug treatment. The chance of falling is reduced by reviewing medicines that cause drowsiness or a drop in blood pressure, checking vision, improving balance and strength, and changing the specific things at home that cause trips. Neither half works alone, and the period straight after a first fracture carries the highest risk of a second.
What can be changed, and what cannot
Prevention is worth thinking about honestly, because the risk has parts that respond to treatment and parts that do not.
What cannot be changed is worth naming first: age, sex, the bone density of earlier decades, and a family history of hip fracture. These raise the risk and they stay raised. What can be changed divides into the two halves of the mechanism. The bone responds to what it is given and to what it is asked to do: calcium and vitamin D, enough protein, weight-bearing and resistance activity, and drug treatment where the density is low enough. The fall responds to the removal of its causes: medicines that sedate or lower blood pressure on standing, unreviewed vision, weak leg muscles, poor balance, and the arrangement of the house.
The two halves add together rather than substitute for one another. A patient whose balance is excellent but whose bone is thin still breaks a hip in a fall. A patient with strong bone who falls repeatedly may fracture a wrist or a vertebra instead. Working on one half while neglecting the other leaves the job half done. None of it requires giving up independence, and most of it is closer to removing an avoidable hazard than to restricting a life.
Strengthening the bone: what the skeleton needs
Bone is living tissue that is continuously broken down and rebuilt, and its strength at any point is the balance between those two processes.
Calcium is the mineral bone is built from, and it is best obtained from food — dairy products, tinned fish eaten with the bones, tofu, and leafy green vegetables. Vitamin D is needed for calcium to be absorbed and used, and deficiency is common in older people and in those who are mostly indoors; it is measured and corrected as a matter of course when a fragility fracture has occurred. Protein is the nutrient most often forgotten: muscle holds the skeleton up and absorbs the energy of a stumble, and most people who break a hip are eating less protein than they need.
Where the measured bone density is low enough, drug treatment changes the balance more powerfully than diet alone. Several families of drug exist, differing in how they are taken and how they act: some reduce the rate at which bone is broken down, others stimulate the building of new bone. The choice depends on how severe the loss is, the other conditions the patient has, which medicines can be taken reliably, and what has already been tried. It warrants a conversation rather than a prescription, including how long treatment will continue and how it will be judged to be working.
It is worth adding what does not work. Calcium taken alone, without attention to vitamin D, protein and activity, does not meaningfully reduce the risk, and neither does a general vitamin tablet. Bone responds over months and years, so the treatments that reduce fracture risk are those taken consistently enough to change the balance over that period.
Reducing the risk of falling
Since bone is slow to change and falls can be addressed quickly, the falls half of prevention usually produces results sooner. It divides into things that are checked, things that are changed and things that are practised.
The things that are checked start with a proper look at why the person is falling, rather than only at how. Blood pressure measured lying and then standing shows the drop that causes the light-headed first few steps. Vision is reviewed, because an out-of-date prescription or a developing cataract changes how the floor and the stairs are seen. The feet are examined and shoes reviewed. Walking and balance are assessed directly, because a slow gait with a short step and reduced arm swing predicts falling and improves with training.
The things that are changed are the medicines that increase the risk — sedatives, sleeping tablets, some antidepressants, and drugs that lower blood pressure — which are discussed below. A walking aid of the right height, used consistently, is one of the most effective measures available to a person at risk of falling, and it is often resisted for reasons worth talking through rather than ignoring.
The things that are practised are described under exercise. Balance and strength respond to training at any age, including in the ninth decade, and the improvements translate directly into fewer falls. It is the part that requires ongoing effort, and it is also the part that gives the greatest sense of control to a patient worried about falling again.
The home: the changes that make the most difference
Most falls in older people happen at home, and most of the hazards that cause them are specific, visible and removable. A home assessment is not about making a house look institutional; it is about removing the few things that are actually dangerous.
- Lighting. The path from the bed to the bathroom at night is the most common place to fall. A night light, a light reachable from the bed, and a torch within reach address it.
- Rugs and mats. Loose rugs, bath mats and trailing cables are the classic trip hazards. Removing them, or fixing them down, removes the hazard rather than relying on remembering it.
- The bathroom. A wet floor, a high bath side and a low toilet are the three most difficult features in the house. Grab rails, a non-slip mat and a raised seat or shower chair make a substantial difference.
- Stairs. A handrail on both sides where possible, a light switch at top and bottom, and edges that are easy to see.
- Chairs and beds. A chair that is too low or too soft makes standing up a struggle, and pushing up from a chair is a common moment to fall. One with arms and a firm seat at knee height is safer.
- Reaching and footwear. Step stools should be replaced by keeping everyday items within easy reach. Shoes with a firm sole and a closed heel are safer indoors as well as outside.
The hazard is often something the person has lived with comfortably for decades — the step into the sitting room, the rug by the door, the low armchair. Changes are much more likely to be kept if the person concerned chooses them: a list handed to a patient and abandoned is worth less than two or three changes the patient actually wants.
Exercise: what actually works for balance and for bone
Exercise appears in both halves of prevention, and the two purposes need different kinds of activity.
For bone, what matters is load. Bone responds to being asked to carry weight and to work against resistance, so walking, stair climbing, standing exercises and resistance work with bands, weights or body weight all contribute. The effect builds over months and depends on the load being enough to be a stimulus. High-impact activity stimulates bone most strongly but may not be safe in a patient with established osteoporosis or a previous fracture, and that judgement belongs to the treating team.
For balance, what matters is practice. The activities with the best evidence are unglamorous and specific: standing on one leg, walking heel to toe, turning and changing direction with control, standing up from a chair repeatedly without using the arms, and standing with the feet close together under supervision. Programmes built around these movements, and the traditional exercise forms that consist largely of slow controlled weight-shifting, reduce falls measurably in older people.
For strength, what matters is resistance. The muscles of the thigh and buttock keep a person upright and recover a stumble, and they respond to training at every age. Three practical points close the section. The programme needs to be sustained, because a burst of activity for a few weeks does not change bone and the balance benefit fades when practice stops. It needs to be progressive. And after a hip fracture it needs to be prescribed rather than improvised, because the limits on weight-bearing depend on the operation that was done.
Reviewing medicines, in both directions
The medicine list is the most productive single thing to examine after a hip fracture, because it is where the two halves of prevention meet: some drugs damage the bone, and some cause the fall.
The drugs that damage bone are led by steroid tablets, which take density away steadily while they are taken and, separately, increase fracture risk at any given density. Where a steroid is needed and will be continued, the bone is protected alongside it rather than monitored until it is too late. Long-term use of some drugs for stomach symptoms is associated with smaller effects on bone, but with so many people taking them they belong in the review.
The drugs that cause falls are the second half, and they are the ones patients most often defend because they help with something. Sedatives and sleeping tablets slow the reaction that turns a stumble into a recovery. Antidepressants of several classes are associated with falls in older people. Medicines for blood pressure and for an enlarged prostate can cause a drop in pressure on standing. Opioid painkillers given for chronic pain reduce alertness and control of movement. None should be stopped abruptly or without advice, but each has an alternative, a lower dose or a timing change that may reduce the risk.
The other direction of review is the medicines that should be added. A fragility fracture is strong evidence that bone treatment is indicated, and a proportion of patients leave hospital after a hip fracture without it because the fracture is treated and the skeleton is not. It is reasonable to ask, before discharge, for the medication plan in writing — what has been stopped, what has been started, and what is being watched.
Why the next fracture is the one to prevent
The strongest single predictor of a hip fracture is a previous fracture, and the period immediately afterwards is when the risk is at its highest. That is why the assessment and treatment are moved into the admission itself rather than booked for a later clinic appointment.
Three things raise the risk after a first fracture. The bone is thinner than it was, having lost bone both to the underlying condition and to the immobility of recovery. The risk of falling is higher in the months after a fracture, because of the loss of strength, the change in confidence, and the medicines and unfamiliar environment of the recovery period. And the muscle has been lost, which is why rehabilitation is part of prevention rather than a separate subject.
Preventing the second fracture is therefore a single programme rather than a set of separate measures: treat the bone, review the medicines, train the balance and the strength, remove the hazards, and keep the review going long enough for the changes to stick. There is one piece of arithmetic worth stating plainly. Treating the fracture and not the bone prevents nothing: the operation repairs the consequences of the bone that gave way, and leaves untouched the condition that made it give way.
Keeping watch: what is measured, and when
Prevention is a programme with checkpoints, and knowing what is measured and roughly how often makes it possible to ask whether it is being done.
Bone density is the usual measure of whether treatment is working, repeated at intervals measured in years rather than months, because bone changes slowly. The result is used alongside the clinical picture rather than on its own: what matters is whether the density is stable or improving and whether any further fractures have occurred. Blood tests are repeated to follow vitamin D and calcium and to keep an eye on the kidneys and the calcium and parathyroid balance. Adherence matters too, because a drug that is not being taken reliably is not protecting anyone; this is one of the arguments in favour of forms of treatment given less often.
Falls are reviewed as a matter of course and not only after an injury. Walking speed, balance and the confidence to go out are re-examined at follow-up, since a decline in these often precedes the fracture by a long way and can be seen coming. Medicines are re-reviewed whenever a new one is started and after every hospital admission, because the list grows with each illness and shrinks only when somebody looks at it.
The most useful question at follow-up is not whether the bone has improved but what is being done about each of the two halves: which drug is being taken for the bone and for how long, which medicines have been changed to reduce the risk of falling, which exercises are being practised and how often, whether the home changes have been made, and when the next review is due.