Joint Replacement & Revision Symptoms
Joint Replacement & Revision Symptoms
A replaced joint that has been comfortable for years rarely speaks without a reason. When it does — a new ache, a change in the way it moves, a joint that no longer feels trustworthy — the pattern of what you feel is genuinely informative, because the handful of things that go wrong with an implant each announce themselves differently. Reading the pattern correctly is the difference between a routine review and an urgent one, and between a joint that needed a different operation entirely and one that needed nothing but a second look.
A new pain in a joint that had been quiet
The single most important fact about a painful replacement is the word new. Pain that has never fully settled since the operation is assessed one way; pain that arrives in a joint that had been comfortable is assessed quite differently, because implants that were sound do not develop new failure modes overnight. When a patient can say "this hip was fine until last spring", the timeline itself becomes evidence: something changed, and the assessment is designed to find what.
Time since surgery shapes the list of likely causes. In the first weeks to months, pain is usually part of normal recovery or reflects a complication of the early period — wound problems, instability, the rare early infection. After the first year, a joint that was genuinely comfortable and then became painful has acquired a new problem, and the five reasons on the main guide — loosening, instability, infection, fracture, or pain from somewhere else — become the working list. Neither period is a reason to endure a worsening joint without an assessment.
The patterns, and what each one suggests
| Pattern | What is usually described | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Start-up pain | Worst with the first steps after sitting or sleeping, easing as the joint warms up, returning after rest; builds gradually over months | The classic pattern of loosening — the implant micro-moving on its bone bed — and the reason serial radiographs are compared over time |
| Rest and night pain | Aching that persists when the joint is still, sometimes worse at night, with warmth, swelling or unexplained fatigue | Pain that does not follow mechanical rules raises the question of infection, which is assessed with blood markers and aspiration — deliberately strict criteria |
| Acute pain after a fall | Sudden severe pain, inability to bear weight, sometimes a visible deformity, after a fall or twist | A periprosthetic fracture until excluded — urgent imaging, because the treatment depends on whether the implant itself is still fixed |
| Giving way or dislocation | The joint feels unreliable, slips or locks, or fully dislocates and needs help to put back | Instability: commonest early after hip replacement, sometimes answered with physiotherapy, sometimes with a procedure to change parts of the implant |
| Wound or scar changes | Fluid draining from an old scar, new redness, a wound that will not close | Never observed from home. Any discharge from a replaced joint is assessed the same week, wherever in the world the patient is |
One caution sits over the whole table: these are inclinations, not verdicts. Start-up pain can come from a tendon; infection can smoulder quietly in some patients, particularly the elderly or those on immune-suppressing medication. The patterns are what make the assessment efficient, not what replace it.
Signs that need urgent attention
Four situations are not for scheduled review. Fever with a painful replaced joint; fluid or pus draining from the scar; a joint that has dislocated and will not stay reduced; and sudden severe pain after a fall with inability to bear weight. Each is assessed immediately — the first two because infection around an implant becomes harder to cure with every week it is left, the last two because the joint may need putting back or the bone fixing without delay.
Two further symptoms belong to the recovery period after any joint operation and to the prevention of clots rather than to the implant: calf pain, swelling or heat in one leg, and sudden breathlessness or chest pain. Both are emergencies anywhere in the world, and neither should be travelled with.
Not every pain around a replaced joint comes from the implant
This is the sentence that saves some patients an unnecessary operation. The spine refers pain to the hip and thigh and can hurt around a replacement that is entirely sound; the bursae over the outer hip and the tendons around the knee produce aching that patients attribute to the implant; and the soft tissues through which the operation was performed have their own healing timeline that can run into a second year. The assessment in the next page exists to separate these — and a painful joint whose implant proves to be well fixed and uninfected is a common and reassuring outcome, not a failed assessment.
The converse also matters: a patient whose pain never quite matches any of the patterns above should still be assessed rather than reassured from a distance. The patterns are efficient, not infallible, and imaging plus blood tests settle the question in a way that correspondence cannot.
When to be seen, and what to bring
The threshold for assessment is low: new pain in a replaced joint deserves an appointment, not a wait. The red-flag signs on this page deserve the same week. Between those poles, a pain that has been stable for months and is not worsening can usually be reviewed routinely — but "reviewed" means examined and imaged, not discussed.
What a patient brings changes what the assessment can conclude. The most valuable items are the operative report and implant identification from the original surgery, every available previous radiograph — because loosening is read by comparison — and a short written account of when the pain began and what it does. For international patients this is exactly what a second-opinion review asks for first, and it is the difference between an opinion and a guess.