FOSUN HEALTH Logo

Joint Replacement & Revision Diagnosis

catalogue

Joint Replacement & Revision Diagnosis

Joint Replacement & Revision Diagnosis

Assessing a replaced joint is a discipline of comparison. A single film of a single moment tells less than the same view taken three years apart; a blood test read alone tells less than two markers read together; and a report that does not name the component it is worried about has not finished the job. The sequence below is deliberately ordered — it separates the five causes of a painful replacement from one another, because each leads to a different operation, and one of them leads to none.

The history: when it started, and what it does

Before any test, three questions are asked precisely. When did the pain begin — and can the patient point to a week, a fall, an infection elsewhere, or a dental procedure? What is its pattern — start-up pain that eases with use, or pain that ignores mechanics and persists at night? And what has been done to this joint before — every operation, every dislocation that was put back, every course of antibiotics. The answers do not make the diagnosis, but they decide which of the five causes sits at the top of the list, and they determine how strictly the infection question needs to be answered.

The record of previous surgery matters more here than patients expect. The identity of the implant, the approach used, whether cement was employed, and how the bone was prepared all change what the imaging is read for and what the revision options would be. This is why the operative report from the original surgery is requested at the very start of any review, and why patients who cannot obtain it are helped to get it rather than waved through.

Radiographs — read as a series, not as a picture

Plain radiographs remain the backbone of assessment, and their value comes from comparison. A component surrounded by a thin lucent line can have looked that way since it was implanted; the same line, widened against the film from two years ago, is loosening announcing itself. Migration — a component that has visibly moved — is even stronger evidence. This is why the request is always for every available previous film, why weight-bearing views are taken for knees, and why a single "normal" radiograph is treated as incomplete rather than as a verdict.

Finding What it suggests
Progressive lucent lines around a component Loosening — the bone is resorbing at the interface; confirmed by change across successive films
Migration or change in component position Established loosening; measured and documented as the baseline for any revision plan
Wear of the plastic liner, or bone reaction to it The bearing surface is generating the particles that drive late loosening; the head and liner are often the first candidates for exchange
A break in the bone around the component Periprosthetic fracture — classified by position and by whether the implant is still fixed
Normal films in a painful joint Neither excludes infection nor ends the assessment; it redirects it to blood tests and aspiration

Blood markers: CRP and ESR, read together

Two blood tests — C-reactive protein and the erythrocyte sedimentation rate — are the standard screen for infection around an implant. They are read as a pair: both normal makes infection unlikely, both raised makes it a live question, one raised is a signal to look at the whole picture. Neither test names an organism, and both rise after any recent surgery or systemic illness, so they are interpreted against the timeline rather than in isolation. Their real value is efficiency: they decide whether the next, more invasive test — aspiration — is needed at all.

Joint aspiration: before antibiotics, not after

Where infection remains possible after bloods and imaging, fluid is drawn from the joint with a needle and sent for culture. The ordering is not bureaucratic: aspiration is performed before any antibiotic is taken, because antibiotics can render an infected joint culture-negative for weeks and destroy the chance of identifying the organism. When infection is eventually treated, knowing the organism and its sensitivities is what allows the antibiotic regimen — and often the number of operations — to be narrowed.

A single negative aspiration does not close the question when suspicion is high; it is repeated, and the criteria for calling infection are deliberately strict — a combination of markers, cells and cultures rather than any one result. That strictness runs in both directions: it prevents a smouldering infection from being missed, and it prevents a painful but sterile joint from being put through a staged reconstruction it did not need.

CT and metal-reduction MRI: the planning images

Where revision is on the table, CT maps the bone stock around each component — how much bone remains, where it is deficient, and what the revision will have to rebuild. This is the imaging that turns "the cup is loose" into a surgical plan with specific components, augments or grafts reserved for the day. MRI with metal-artifact-reduction sequences shows the soft tissues around an implant: collections of fluid, muscle, the bone-metal interface. It is not a first-line test, and it answers soft-tissue questions rather than fixation ones — but in the assessment of a suspected infection or an unclear painful joint it earns its place.

What a complete report must say

The assessment is finished when four questions have answers, in writing: which component — or whether the pain is from the spine or the soft tissues and the implant is sound; whether that component is fixed or loose; whether the picture is infected or aseptic; and how much bone stock remains. Those four answers are what the treatment page needs to match a patient to the right operation — and in the minority of cases where the answer is "the implant is fine", they are what allow the patient to leave the process with confidence rather than with a referral for surgery they did not need.

For patients considering a second opinion, this is also the list to hold any opinion against — our own included. A written review that does not answer the four questions is an impression, and impressions are a thin basis on which to fly across the world for surgery.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need new imaging if I brought films from last year?

Yes — both, not either. The old films are what make the new ones interpretable: loosening is read as change over time, so the comparison is the finding. The current films establish where the joint stands now and look for anything the interval might have added. A review that relies on old images alone can be several years out of date, and one that takes new images without the old ones throws away the single most informative test in this field.

Why can't a blood test alone rule out infection?

Because the markers are sensitive but not specific: CRP and ESR rise with any inflammation, including recent surgery, dental infections and systemic illness, and they can be normal in some chronic low-grade implant infections. That is why they are read as a pair, against the timeline, and why a raised pair is followed by aspiration rather than by treatment. The opposite direction matters too — normal markers make infection unlikely and often spare the patient an invasive test.

What if the assessment finds my implant is fine?

Then the assessment has done its job. A well-fixed, uninfected implant in a painful joint means the pain is coming from somewhere else — the spine, bursae, tendons — and those problems have their own treatments, none of which involve reopening the joint. Patients are sometimes surprised how often this is the outcome; the honest framing is that the assessment exists as much to prevent unnecessary revision surgery as to plan necessary surgery.

How long does the full assessment take?

The imaging and blood work are typically completed within a day or two of arriving, and the aspiration, where needed, is a needle procedure with results in days. What takes discipline is the sequence: aspiration before antibiotics, cultures given time to grow, and the infection criteria applied strictly. A rushed assessment that skips a step can lead to the wrong operation, which costs far more time than the assessment saved.

Ask for the four answers in writing

Send the operative report and implant identification, every previous radiograph, and any recent blood results, and tell us the specific question you need answered. A joint specialist will return a written opinion within about 48 hours of complete records arriving — structured around the four answers: which component, fixed or loose, infected or aseptic, and how much bone remains.

Want to see the whole process first? Your full medical journey, step by step →

Book an Appointment Request a Video Consultation

Follow Fosun Health

Apply for an Appointment

Do you have test results*