Lumbar Disc Herniation Diagnosis
Lumbar Disc Herniation Diagnosis
A diagnosis of disc-related sciatica is built in a fixed order: the history and examination decide whether a nerve root is involved and which one, the scan shows what is pressing on it, and further tests are added only when those two disagree. Nothing here is ordered for completeness.
What the examination measures, and why
The examination exists to answer two questions that no scan can answer: is this a nerve root, and is that nerve still working. It also produces numbers that can be compared at the next visit, which is what makes a decision possible later rather than only today.
With the patient lying flat, the leg is lifted with the knee straight. Pain reproduced in the leg below about 60 degrees is a positive finding; pain reproduced in the opposite leg when the unaffected side is lifted is more specific still. These two tests are repeated at each visit because a change in them often precedes a change in symptoms.
L4 is tested by the quadriceps and rising from a squat, L5 by extending the big toe and walking on the heels, S1 by standing on tiptoe on one foot. This is graded on a standard scale and written down, because "slightly weak" is not comparable between visits — a grade is.
The band of altered sensation is mapped, and the knee (L4) and ankle (S1) reflexes are compared side to side. A reflex that is absent on one side supports the diagnosis but rarely changes the plan on its own.
Spinal movement, tenderness, deformity and the way the patient walks are all recorded. Posture and gait findings can point to instability, to a central herniation, or to a cause outside the spine — and they are easy to miss if the examination stops at the leg.
What imaging can and cannot show
Each test answers a different question, and the sequence matters because some of them prove more than they can deliver.
| Test | The question it answers |
|---|---|
| MRI of the lumbar spine | Where the disc material is, which nerve it displaces, and how much room the canal leaves. It shows the disc and the nerve in one image, which no other single test does. |
| Standing lumbar radiograph | Whether there is instability, deformity or a stress fracture, and it is required before any fusion. It does not show a herniation. |
| CT (or CT myelography) | Bone detail, and imaging when MRI cannot be performed — for example with an incompatible pacemaker or severe claustrophobia. |
| Dynamic (bending) films | Whether one vertebra is moving abnormally on the next, which changes a decompression into a decompression with fusion. |
MRI is requested when the symptoms persist despite a fair period of non-surgical treatment, when there is a neurological deficit, when the pain is atypical, or when an injection or an operation is being considered. It is not a routine first step for a first episode of mild leg pain, because most adults have disc changes that have nothing to do with their complaints — and acting on an incidental finding is one of the commoner reasons patients end up having an operation they did not need.
When nerve studies are worth adding
Nerve conduction studies and electromyography measure how a nerve is conducting rather than what surrounds it. They are not part of a routine work-up, but they answer two specific questions well.
- Is the problem in the spine or further down the leg? A compression at the knee or ankle, or a generalised neuropathy, can produce numbness in the foot that looks like S1 involvement until the study separates them.
- How old is the problem, and is it recovering? Findings change over weeks, so comparing studies over time can show whether a nerve is recovering — useful when the examination and the scan disagree, or when symptoms persist after an operation has apparently removed the compression.
Where symptoms are clearly radicular, the examination and MRI agree, and the patient is improving, nerve studies add cost and delay without changing anything. Where the picture is mixed, they frequently change the diagnosis.
When the picture is atypical
Certain features should stop the process moving along the usual disc pathway and direct it somewhere else. They are not common, which is exactly why they need to be asked about rather than waited for.
Pain with specific behaviour
Night pain that wakes the patient, pain that is unrelenting rather than positional, fever, unexplained weight loss, or a history of cancer: these call for imaging of the whole region, and for blood tests, rather than for an injection.
A history that does not fit a disc
Significant trauma or a minor injury in someone on long-term steroids or with known osteoporosis raises the question of a vertebral fracture rather than a disc — a quite different diagnosis with a different treatment.
Findings above the usual levels
A nerve level that does not correspond to the distribution, symptoms in both legs with brisk reflexes, or bladder involvement from the outset should prompt imaging of the whole spine and a neurology opinion.
Symptoms that continue after successful surgery
Persistent pain after a technically satisfactory discectomy usually means the diagnosis was incomplete rather than the operation having failed. The examination and the nerve studies are re-read before any further surgery is considered.
Arranging a review from abroad
Disc problems are well suited to remote review, because the two decisive pieces of information — the images and the clinical findings — both travel without loss.
What to send
Every MRI you have as image files with their dates — earlier studies matter as much as the latest, because a change between two dates is often the whole story. Add any radiograph or CT, and the reports if you have them.
What to describe
Where the pain runs, whether it crosses the knee, what makes it worse, whether there is numbness or weakness and whether it is changing. One paragraph written in your own words is more useful than a page of translated terminology.
What you will receive
A written opinion: which nerve the pattern points to, whether it is irritated or losing function, whether an operation is indicated now, and if not, what would change that. Where surgery is likely, a range of approaches is set out with an itemised estimate.
You should also receive one thing that is often missing: an explicit statement of what will be done if the answer turns out to be no operation. That is a common and valid outcome, and it should come with a plan rather than with an open-ended invitation to return.