Joint Stiffness & Cartilage Injury Diagnosis
Joint Stiffness & Cartilage Injury Diagnosis
The assessment of a stiff or cartilage-injured joint is built on two disciplines: measure, and exclude. Motion is measured as numbers and compared over time, because the trend is the finding. Scar tissue is blamed for stiffness only after infection and mechanical impostors have been excluded, because they present identically. And cartilage is graded by depth and area before any repair is promised, because the grading is what decides which repair fits — or whether repair is the wrong conversation entirely.
History: what was done to the joint, and when
Two dates organise everything. The first is the date of the injury or operation — stiffness is read against the weeks since it, and a cartilage lesion against the years of load since the twisting injury that started it. The second is the date motion stopped improving: a joint recovering normally gains range week on week, and the plateau-and-decline that replaces that trend is the single most useful fact in the history.
The rest is inventory: every operation the joint has had, every period of immobilisation — casts, splints, bed rest — and every injection. These matter because they are the risk factors themselves: multiple prior operations and prolonged immobility are the strongest associations with arthrofibrosis, and the surgical notes of the last operation tell the surgeon what the joint looked like inside.
Examination: numbers first, then the special tests
Range of motion is measured with a goniometer and written down as two numbers — flexion, and extension measured as degrees short of straight. The extension figure is recorded with particular care, because a lag of a few degrees is the finding that changes management fastest. The rest of the examination looks for the causes behind the numbers: where the joint catches (a consistent angle suggests a mechanical block; a random one suggests a loose body), whether the quadriceps fires, whether the ligaments are stable, and whether alignment puts the load where the cartilage is thinnest. Swelling, warmth and the skin changes of complex regional pain syndrome are noted — they redirect the workup rather than the treatment.
Imaging: radiographs for the frame, MRI for the surface
Weight-bearing radiographs come first and answer the frame questions: joint space, alignment, bone blocks, and — after a replacement — component position. MRI with cartilage-sensitive sequences is the examination on which cartilage decisions rest: it shows the depth and area of a defect, the state of the cartilage around it, the meniscus and ligaments the repair would depend on, and — in a stiff joint — the scar bands themselves. Where a replacement is present and malrotation is suspected, CT measures the components' angles. Long-leg films are added whenever alignment will influence surgery, because a repair placed under an off-centre load fails by schedule.
Grading: ICRS for depth, cm² for area, degrees for motion
Cartilage defects are graded by the ICRS scale: grade I, softening and fibrillation; II, a defect under half the cartilage's depth; III, more than half the depth or down to the bone beneath; IV, full-thickness loss with exposed bone. Depth decides severity; area in cm² decides which repair fits — roughly under 2 cm² suits marrow stimulation, 1–4 cm² suits cartilage transfer, larger full-thickness defects suit cell-based implants. Motion loss is graded on the parallel scale from the landing page: mild 90–100°, moderate 70–89°, severe below 70° of flexion, with extension recorded separately. These numbers are not academic: they are the language in which repair candidacy is written.
Exclusions: what must be ruled out before scar tissue is blamed
Arthrofibrosis is a diagnosis of exclusion, and the exclusions are ordered by how well they hide. Infection comes first — blood inflammatory markers (C-reactive protein and erythrocyte sedimentation rate) and, where they are raised or the picture is unclear, joint aspiration with culture; this discipline is non-negotiable after a joint replacement, where infection can present as nothing but progressive stiffness (the assessment of a painful replacement follows exactly this order). Component malposition after a replacement is next — CT measures what radiographs suggest. Complex regional pain syndrome shows itself in the skin, not the joint. Muscle guarding is exposed when the joint moves further under anaesthesia than awake. Only when these are excluded does the stiffness earn the name arthrofibrosis — and the treatment ladder that follows.
What a complete assessment must answer
The workup is complete when three questions have written answers. How much motion is lost — flexion and extension as numbers, with the trend across weeks. What is blocking it — scar tissue, capsule, a mechanical block, or a component, with infection explicitly excluded on the record. And whether the cartilage problem is focal or diffuse — depth, area, and the health of the joint around the defect: alignment, ligaments, meniscus, the opposing surface. Those three answers map one-to-one onto the treatment ladder, and they are what any second opinion — including ours — should be judged against.