Hallux Valgus & Foot Deformity Prevention
Hallux Valgus & Foot Deformity Prevention
This page is about what can honestly be done to reduce the chance that a foot deformity becomes painful, and to reduce the chance that it progresses. It begins with a distinction that makes the rest of the page useful rather than disappointing. Where the alignment has already changed, nothing on this page will put it back; the measures below change how the foot is loaded and can keep a susceptible foot comfortable for years. Where the foot is at risk because of an inflammatory condition, a neuropathy or a generalised laxity, there are measures that genuinely alter what happens to the foot. And where a deformity is being watched rather than treated, what matters is having a defined plan for noticing change, so that a decision is made on evidence rather than on a recollection.
Footwear: the one measure with a clear mechanism
If only one thing is done about a foot with this group of conditions, it should be this, and it is worth doing properly rather than approximately. The mechanism is simple: a shoe applies force to the foot, and the shape of that force either follows the shape of the foot or fights it.
- Measure the width across the ball of the foot while standing, in the afternoon, and compare it with the internal width of the shoes actually worn. The commonest finding is that the length of the foot has determined the shoe size while the width has been ignored, and that the shoes are too narrow exactly where the pressure is.
- Look for a toe box that is both wide and deep. Width relieves the prominence on the inner side; depth relieves pressure on top of the toes, which matters where the great toe has begun to ride up or a lesser toe has curled. A shoe that is wide but shallow will still press on a raised toe joint.
- Keep the heel low. Raising the heel transfers load to the forefoot, so heel height is a treatment variable rather than a matter of taste. Where a formal or occupational shoe is unavoidable, the time spent in it is worth limiting and the fit worth checking.
- Choose an upper that gives and a sole that is firm. A soft upper deforms around a prominence instead of pressing on it; a stable sole distributes the load of walking over a larger area of the foot.
- Buy shoes at the end of the day, and where the two feet differ in size — which is common — fit the larger one.
- Use inserts where they are provided, because an insole that redistributes load under the ball of the foot only works while it is in the shoe.
The reason this belongs at the top of a prevention page is not that it prevents the deformity in an absolute sense. It is that footwear is the factor with the clearest mechanism by which symptoms begin, it is entirely within the patient’s control, and it is the measure most likely to keep a foot comfortable and functioning without an operation.
The two situations where acting early genuinely changes things
Most foot deformity is watched rather than treated, and that is appropriate. There are two situations, though, in which early attention changes what happens rather than merely when it happens.
- A young foot with the shape and a family history. Where the foot anatomy that predisposes to the deformity is present, and where it runs in the family, a young person has the longest time in which the alignment can change. Attention here is not an operation; it is footwear that fits from the outset, awareness of what to watch for, and a photograph or a measurement recorded so that change can be judged later. Where the deformity has already begun and is progressing in a young foot, the discussion about treatment is worth having earlier rather than later, because correcting an established deformity is more involved than correcting a developing one.
- Inflammatory arthritis affecting the forefoot. Here the joints are being altered by an active disease, and controlling it changes what happens to the foot. This is the situation in which medical treatment genuinely alters the outcome, and it is the reason a foot that is changing shape in someone with an inflammatory condition is assessed with more urgency than one that has been stable for years.
“Early” here does not mean early surgery. In both situations, the first measures are the same as for anyone else — footwear, load, and control of whatever underlying condition is present — and the value of acting early is that a decision can be made on a record rather than on an impression.
Load, activity and the muscles that support the foot
How much load the forefoot receives, and how well the foot is equipped to handle it, are both within reach. The aim is not to rest the foot but to keep it working while reducing the forces that cause symptoms.
- Reduce the time spent standing where it is possible, and vary it where it is not. Long uninterrupted periods on the feet load the forefoot continuously, and the tissues over a prominence swell as the day progresses. Breaking up the standing and sitting for short periods is more effective than resting afterwards.
- Match the footwear to the activity rather than to the occasion. The load of walking on hard, flat surfaces in thin-soled shoes is different from the load of walking on grass in shoes with a sole that absorbs some of it.
- Keep the calf, the ankle and the muscles of the foot in condition. A foot whose supporting muscles are weak works harder, and strength around the ankle and calf is one of the few things that can be improved rather than merely accommodated. This is also what makes recovery easier if an operation is ever needed.
- Manage body weight where it is relevant. Weight is one of the loads the forefoot carries, and reducing it where it is appropriate reduces the force through the joint. Medication for gout, and control of blood sugar in diabetes, are also part of protecting the same joint.
- Distinguish load pain from other pain. Pain that comes on with activity and settles with rest behaves like a load problem and responds to the measures above. Pain that is present at rest, that wakes the person at night, or that comes with redness and swelling in a single joint needs assessment rather than adjustment.
Protecting a foot that cannot feel
In a foot with reduced sensation, prevention changes character. The warning system that would normally make a person notice pressure and change their shoes has gone, so protection has to be built in from outside and checked deliberately.
- Inspect the feet every day, including between the toes and the sole, and use a mirror or ask someone to look where the person cannot see. The aim is to find a red area or a blister before the skin breaks.
- Never walk barefoot, including indoors, because an unrecognised injury on an insensate foot is the commonest start of a serious problem.
- Have footwear checked rather than chosen by feel. A shoe that fits and that accommodates the deformity, with an insole that redistributes pressure under the areas at risk, is a medical measure in this group rather than a comfort measure.
- Do not treat corns or callus yourself with sharp instruments or chemical preparations, and do not apply heat to the feet. Both are capable of producing an injury that will not be felt.
- Report any red area, blister, break in the skin or change in colour the same day. The rule in an insensate foot is that a problem which would be trivial in a normal foot is assessed rather than observed.
- Keep the circulation in mind. Where the blood supply is reduced, healing is slower and any break in the skin is more serious. The pulses and the skin should be checked at routine reviews rather than only when a problem appears.
This is the group in which the relationship between deformity and prevention is most direct. A deformity concentrates load on particular points of the sole, and in a foot that cannot feel it, the first sign of that load is often skin damage rather than pain. That is why a foot with both a deformity and reduced sensation is assessed and protected differently from a foot with either alone.
What prevention cannot do, stated plainly
It is worth being explicit about the limits, both because the alternatives are sold to patients and because an accurate expectation is what makes the measures above worth doing.
- It cannot reverse an alignment that has already changed. No shoe, pad, spacer or splint moves the great toe back towards the midline or reduces the angle between the first and second metatarsals in an adult foot. Devices that claim to correct the deformity are not supported by the evidence, and the honest role of padding and spacers is to relieve pressure.
- It cannot change the way the foot is built. Where the tendency is anatomical and inherited, footwear can reduce symptoms and may reduce the rate of change, but the underlying shape remains.
- It cannot substitute for treating an active condition. Where inflammatory arthritis, gout or a neurological condition is driving the change, footwear alone does not address it.
- It is not a reason to delay assessment when something has changed. “I will try wider shoes first” is reasonable advice for a stable, mildly symptomatic foot. It is not reasonable for a foot whose alignment is visibly changing, for a joint that has become painful on walking, or for a foot with reduced sensation that has developed a red area.
A plan for watching a foot that is not being operated on
Where the decision is to manage a foot conservatively, the most useful thing to come out of an assessment is a defined plan for noticing change rather than a general instruction to come back if it gets worse. The elements below are what such a plan contains.
- A baseline record. A standing radiograph if one has not been taken, photographs taken standing from above and from the side, the shoe size currently worn and the width of the standing foot. The purpose is comparison, and the record is only useful if it exists before the change.
- What to watch for, specifically. The alignment becoming visibly different between the two feet; a second toe beginning to curl or to ride upwards; callus appearing or moving under the ball of the foot; shoes becoming harder to fit for the same nominal size; and pain beginning to come on without a shoe.
- What to do between reviews. Continue footwear that fits and padding where it helps; keep the foot and the ankle active; and where there is an underlying condition such as gout or diabetes, keep it controlled rather than treating it as a separate matter.
- When to come back. A stated interval for review where the deformity is being watched, and an explicit statement of the changes that justify coming sooner rather than waiting for the next appointment.
- What would change the plan. The findings that would move the discussion from observation to treatment, and the point at which an operation would be worth considering — described in terms of pain and function rather than in terms of the angle.
- Who to contact, and how. Where a foot is being monitored remotely, a photograph and a short description can answer most of the questions that arise between reviews, and having that route stated in advance avoids the situation where a patient waits for an appointment to ask something that could be answered in a day.