FOSUN HEALTH Logo

Hallux Valgus & Foot Deformity Diagnosis

catalogue

Hallux Valgus & Foot Deformity Diagnosis

Hallux Valgus & Foot Deformity Diagnosis

The diagnosis of a foot deformity is usually visible from across the room, and that is precisely why it is worth being careful about: what needs to be established is not what the foot looks like but three separate things. How far has the alignment actually moved, measured under load? Where is the pain coming from — the shoe, the joint, a stretched nerve, or load transferred elsewhere? And can the deformity still be corrected by hand, which decides whether anything other than an operation has a chance of helping? The examination answers the second and third of these, and a single radiograph taken standing answers the first.

The history: three questions, asked in a specific way

The history is short and it is structured around the three questions, because each of them changes something in the plan. The useful part is not the description of the foot but the answers to these.

  • Is the alignment changing, and over what period? A deformity that has been the same for ten years is managed differently from one that has moved over the past two. The comparison is made against earlier radiographs, earlier photographs or a recollection that can be dated — “these shoes fitted two summers ago” is a more useful answer than “it has got worse”.
  • Where is the pain, and what brings it on? The three patterns described on the symptoms page are separated deliberately: pain from the shoe that eases when the shoe comes off; pain deep in the joint on walking or pushing off; and pain under the ball of the foot or in the second toe. A patient who can say which of these is theirs has already done most of the useful work.
  • What can the foot no longer do, and what has been given up? The distance that can be walked, the hours that can be spent standing, whether a normal shoe can be worn for a working day, and which activities have been abandoned. This is recorded because it is the measurement that treatment is aimed at, and because it can be compared afterwards.

Three further pieces of history change the direction of the assessment rather than its detail. A diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis means the forefoot is being altered by joint disease and that controlling it is part of the treatment. A diagnosis of gout explains attacks of acute pain that are not related to the deformity and can be treated in their own right. A diagnosis of diabetes or of any condition that reduces sensation in the feet changes the whole plan, because a foot that cannot feel pressure will not report a problem until the skin has broken. Family history is also recorded, not because it changes what can be done but because it is the most consistent factor identified and it is often the explanation a patient is looking for.

The examination: what is done standing, and what is done by hand

The examination has two halves and both are necessary. The first is performed with the patient standing, bearing weight on both feet, because that is the position in which the foot is symptomatic. The second is performed sitting, and it is entirely about movement.

  • Standing: the alignment, and where the foot takes its load. The position of the great toe, the prominence of the joint, the shape of the arch in stance, the position of the lesser toes and the site of any callus under the forefoot are all recorded with the patient standing. The site of the callus is the most informative single observation, because it shows where the load has actually gone rather than where it should be.
  • The flexibility test. With the patient sitting and the ankle relaxed, the great toe is brought back towards the midline by hand. The amount of correction that can be achieved is the measurement that separates a flexible deformity from a fixed one. A foot that straightens easily is one in which soft tissue balance and load still matter and in which an operation can be planned with confidence about the correction; a foot that will not straighten has a fixed component that changes both the procedure and the prognosis.
  • The stability of the first ray. The base of the first metatarsal is moved in relation to the bone behind it. Abnormal movement here means the whole ray is shifting rather than just the toe, and it is one of the strongest determinants of which operation will hold. It is a clinical finding: no radiograph shows it directly.
  • The joint surface. The range of upward bending at the base of the great toe is measured, and the joint is felt for crepitus. A joint that has lost its upward bend and grinds is a worn joint, not merely a deviated one.
  • The shoes, compared with the foot. The width of the shoe is compared with the width of the standing foot. This takes a moment and produces a finding that occasionally makes every other investigation unnecessary.
  • The rest of the foot, and the gait. The ankle, the arch, the lesser toes and the way the patient walks are all examined, because a deformity at one part of the foot changes the load elsewhere and the patient often feels it elsewhere.
  • Sensation and the blood supply. Sensation is tested with simple instruments and the pulses and skin are checked. These are routine, and in a patient with diabetes they are the findings that determine whether the priority is correction of the deformity or protection of the skin.

The standing radiograph, and why position matters more than the machine

The imaging of hallux valgus and of most foot deformity is a single radiograph, taken with the patient standing and bearing weight on both feet. Nothing about the equipment is unusual; everything about the position is. A film taken with the foot lying on a table shows the foot at rest, which is not the configuration that produces the symptoms, and it can understate a deformity or fail to show it at all.

From the weight-bearing film, five things are recorded and each of them is used:

  • The hallux valgus angle — the angle between the first metatarsal and the great toe, which measures how far the toe has drifted across.
  • The intermetatarsal angle — the angle between the first and second metatarsals, which measures how far the first ray has moved away from the second.
  • Whether the joint is congruent or incongruent. In a congruent joint the two surfaces still face one another and the toe can be brought back by hand; in an incongruent joint they have rotated away from each other and the correction requires more than a soft tissue release. This distinction, not the size of the bump, is often what determines the choice of operation.
  • The position of the sesamoid bones. Two small bones sit beneath the first metatarsal head inside the tendon. As the alignment changes, they are carried out of position, and how far they have travelled is a measure of how much of the deformity has occurred at the joint itself.
  • The joint surface. Narrowing of the space between the bones, irregularity, or a cyst within the bone indicate that the joint has begun to wear, which changes the operation entirely and may make fusion the appropriate choice.

When other imaging is used. Cross-sectional imaging is not routine for this group of conditions, and when it is requested there is a specific question behind it. MRI is used where a soft tissue or inflammatory cause is suspected — for example where a nerve entrapment or an inflammatory arthritis is possible — or where pain is out of proportion to the deformity found. CT, or weight-bearing CT, is used where a complex deformity, a deformity involving the midfoot or the hindfoot, or a previous operation needs to be planned in three dimensions. Ultrasound is useful for a specific soft tissue question. None of these replaces the standing radiograph for measuring alignment.

Reading the measurements: what the angles do and do not tell you

The angles are grouped into mild, moderate and severe, and the grouping is used to communicate the size of a deformity and to narrow the choice of operation. It is not a statement about the patient, and the temptation to read it as one is worth resisting explicitly.

GroupingHallux valgus angleIntermetatarsal angleTypical consequence for planning
NormalUnder 15°Under 9°Alignment is not the problem; look elsewhere for the source of the pain
Mild15–20°Under 11°Footwear and padding are the first measures; an operation for pain, if needed, is usually directed distally
Moderate20–40°11–16°The choice of procedure becomes the central question, and its site is chosen from where the deformity lies
SevereOver 40°Over 16°The whole ray has moved; the correction has to include the origin of the deformity, and the second toe is commonly addressed at the same time

What the angles do not tell you. They do not say how much pain the foot produces, which is a separate axis recorded from the history. They do not say whether the first ray is stable at its base, which is a clinical finding and which changes the operation. They do not by themselves distinguish a flexible deformity from a fixed one, which is established by moving the toe. And they do not capture the state of the joint surface or the position of the sesamoids, both of which are read from the same film but recorded separately.

What the angles do tell you, reliably. They put the deformity on a scale that can be compared over time, which is the only way to answer the first of the three questions honestly. A measurement recorded today and another in two years say whether the alignment is changing, and by how much, in a way that a photograph or a memory cannot. They also give the operation a target: the correction is planned to a specific alignment rather than to a visual impression, which is why the film is taken before the operation and again afterwards.

What has to be excluded before the deformity is treated as mechanical

A foot with an obvious deformity can still be producing pain for a reason that is not mechanical, and several of those reasons change the treatment substantially. They are looked for deliberately rather than assumed absent.

  • Inflammatory arthritis. Pain and swelling in several joints of both feet, morning stiffness lasting more than an hour, and a pattern that does not follow activity suggest an inflammatory process. It is investigated with blood tests and, where appropriate, imaging, and controlling it is part of the foot treatment rather than a separate matter.
  • Gout and other crystal arthritis. Attacks that come on over hours with severe pain, redness and swelling are treated in their own right, and a foot that has both a bunion and gout needs both addressed.
  • Hallux rigidus. A worn, stiff joint rather than a deviated one, distinguished by the loss of upward bending and by the appearance of the joint surface on the radiograph.
  • Nerve entrapment between the metatarsals. Pain, burning or numbness in the toes that does not follow the deformity, and that is often worse in narrow shoes.
  • Stress fracture of a metatarsal. Localised tenderness over one bone with a history of a change in activity, which is treated by rest and protection rather than by an operation.
  • Peripheral neuropathy and peripheral arterial disease. Loss of sensation or an inadequate blood supply changes the priority from correcting the shape to protecting the skin, and in a foot with either, an operation is planned with those limits in mind.
  • Infection. Redness, warmth, swelling and systemic upset in a foot require infection to be excluded before any elective procedure is considered.

What a complete assessment has to answer

An assessment of a foot deformity is complete when it has produced answers rather than a description. The answers below are the ones that determine what happens next, and a patient is entitled to ask for each of them.

  • Which deformity is primary. Whether the problem originates at the great toe, at the base of the first metatarsal, at the lesser toes, in the midfoot or in the hindfoot, and whether more than one is involved.
  • The measured alignment, on a standing film. The two angles and the three further findings, recorded so that they can be compared next time.
  • Whether the deformity is flexible or fixed, and whether the first ray is stable. These two findings decide whether support can help and which part of the ray an operation would address.
  • Which structure is producing the pain. The prominence and its bursa, the joint, a stretched nerve, or load transferred to the second metatarsal or the ball of the foot.
  • What the options are, including doing nothing. With the reasoning: what footwear and padding can achieve, what they cannot, and what an operation would and would not change. Where a period of conservative management is sensible, the length of that period and the point at which it would be reconsidered should be stated.
  • If an operation is proposed, which part of the ray is being realigned and why. This is the single most useful question a patient can ask, because it is the decision on which whether the correction holds depends.

Bringing the records. The assessment is faster and the opinion firmer when the material arrives in advance: photographs of the foot taken standing from above and from the side, any radiographs including older films so that progression can be judged, reports of blood tests if inflammatory arthritis or gout has been considered, the shoes that cause the problem, and a list of medicines. Where a radiograph was taken lying down, say so, because it may need to be repeated standing for the alignment to be measured. Our foot and ankle team returns a written opinion within about 48 hours of complete records arriving, setting out what the measurements show, which structure appears to be producing the symptoms, and what the reasonable options are.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need an MRI for a bunion?

Usually not. The diagnosis and the planning of hallux valgus rest on the clinical examination and on a standing radiograph, which between them establish the alignment, the state of the joint, and whether the deformity is flexible or fixed. An MRI shows soft tissue well and bone alignment poorly, and it is not the right instrument for measuring a deformity. It is used when there is a specific soft tissue question to answer — a suspected nerve entrapment or an inflammatory process, for instance — or when the pain is out of proportion to what the examination finds. If an MRI has been done and a standing radiograph has not, the radiograph is the one that will change the plan.

Why does the radiograph have to be taken standing?

Because the deformity is a change in alignment under load, and a foot lying on a table is not loaded. In a foot imaged non-weight-bearing, the bones can fall back towards a position that looks much more normal than the foot does when the patient is standing on it, so the angles measured are smaller and the deformity can appear milder than it is or be missed altogether. The difference is large enough to change the choice of operation, which is why the film is taken with the patient standing on both feet, and why a report based on a non-weight-bearing film may need to be repeated rather than acted on.

What does it mean if the joint is described as incongruent?

It is a description of how the two surfaces of the joint at the base of the great toe are facing. In a congruent joint the surfaces still face one another and the great toe can be brought back towards the midline by hand, which means the deformity is largely one of soft tissue balance and load. In an incongruent joint the surfaces have rotated away from each other, the sesamoid bones have been carried out of position, and the correction requires more than releasing the tight structures — it requires the bone to be repositioned. The distinction is worth knowing about because it is one of the findings that most often determines which operation is appropriate, and it is not visible from the outside.

Can the measurement be repeated to see whether it is getting worse?

Yes, and that is one of the most useful things a radiograph does. Because the angles are measured in a standard way on a weight-bearing film, a measurement taken now can be compared with one taken two or five years ago, which answers the first of the three questions — whether the alignment is actually changing — in a way that a photograph or a recollection cannot. Where the earlier film was not taken standing, the comparison is unreliable and it is worth saying so; in that case the current standing film becomes the baseline, and a further film in a year or two will show the trend.

Send the standing radiograph and the photographs for a written opinion

Send the standing (weight-bearing) radiograph of both feet as an image rather than only as a report, photographs taken standing from above and from the side, any older radiographs or reports so that progression can be judged, the results of any blood tests done for inflammatory arthritis or gout, a description of where the pain is and what brings it on, which shoes and pads have been tried, and your insurance details if you are covered. Our foot and ankle team will return a written opinion within about 48 hours of complete records arriving, setting out what the measurements show, which structure appears to be producing the symptoms, and what the reasonable options are.

Want to see the whole process first? Your full medical journey, step by step →

Book an Appointment Request a Video Consultation

WhatsApp +86 172-7459-8280 · EN / 中文 · 24h within business hours

Follow Fosun Health

Apply for an Appointment

Do you have test results*