Rotator Cuff Tear Diagnosis
Rotator Cuff Tear Diagnosis
An imaging report that says only that a rotator cuff tear is present has answered the least useful of the available questions. The words that change treatment are numbers: how many centimetres the tear spans, how far the tendon has pulled away from the bone, and how much of the muscle has been replaced by fat. This page sets out how each of those is measured, why the physical examination still comes first, and what a useful report should contain.
The history: which tear is this?
The history separates the two conditions that share a diagnosis, and it does so in a few minutes. Was there an event — a fall, a sudden pull, a wrenching movement — or did the shoulder decline over months? How long ago did it begin, and what has the shoulder stopped doing since? Which movements hurt, and does the pain wake the patient at night? Has the arm become weaker, or only sorer?
Three items in the history carry disproportionate weight. The first is mechanism: an identifiable injury raises the possibility of an acute tear that may still be within the window where straightforward repair is most reliable. The second is progressive weakness, which points to the tendon rather than to inflamed tissue around it. The third is what has already been tried: a shoulder that has completed a proper course of physiotherapy without improvement has answered a question, and the answer is that imaging is now indicated.
The examination: active before passive, then each tendon
The examination is deliberately ordered, and the first step is the one that most often redirects everything that follows.
Active and passive range of motion. The patient is asked to move the shoulder, and then the examiner moves it. A cuff tear characteristically produces a large gap between the two: the patient cannot lift the arm, but the examiner can move it much further with little pain. A frozen shoulder produces the opposite pattern — passive movement is also restricted, in every direction, and often markedly so. Because a frozen shoulder is treated with time and movement rather than surgery, this single comparison determines which pathway the patient is on.
Resistance testing tendon by tendon. Each of the four tendons has a test that isolates it reasonably well: resisted elevation with the arm in the plane of the scapula and the thumb turned down for supraspinatus; resisted external rotation for infraspinatus; the external rotation lag sign, in which the arm is passively rotated out and fails to hold the position; and lift-off or belly-press for subscapularis. The examiner is listening for two different things — whether the movement hurts, and whether it is genuinely weak. The second is the more consequential finding.
What each imaging test is for
The three modalities answer different questions, and a good workup uses them for what each does best.
Plain radiographs come first, not primarily to see the tendon but to see the bones around it: the shape of the acromion, the height of the subacromial space, the state of the acromioclavicular joint, and — in long-standing large tears — whether the humeral head has begun to migrate upward within the joint. That last finding changes the operation on offer, because a shoulder in which the ball has risen is no longer a straightforward repair candidate. Radiographs also exclude the fractures and arthritis that can masquerade as cuff pain.
Ultrasound is the workhorse of shoulder soft-tissue imaging. It is quick, inexpensive, allows the shoulder to be moved during the examination so that a tendon can be watched gliding and a tear seen opening, and it is accurate for full-thickness tears in experienced hands. Its limitation is equally real: the quality of the result depends heavily on the operator, and it is less dependable for partial-thickness tears and for judging how much fat has entered the muscle.
MRI is the examination that produces the numbers a surgeon needs. It shows tear size and configuration, the degree of retraction, the quality of the remaining tendon, muscle volume and fatty infiltration, and the state of the long head of biceps and the labrum — all in one study, in a form that can be compared on repeat examinations. Where a partial-thickness tear is suspected and the result will change the plan, MR arthrography improves sensitivity by distending the joint.
Sizing the tear: depth, length and configuration
Tears are described in two dimensions before any judgement is made about them.
Depth first. A partial-thickness tear involves part of the tendon's substance — on the articular surface, on the bursal surface, or within the tendon — and is graded by what fraction of the tendon's thickness is involved. A full-thickness tear runs through the entire tendon. The distinction governs the first branch in treatment, because many partial-thickness tears improve with rehabilitation while a full-thickness tear has no capacity to heal itself.
Then size and morphology. A full-thickness tear is measured in centimetres across the tendon, and grouped as small (under 1 cm), medium (1–3 cm), large (3–5 cm) or massive (over 5 cm). Beyond the single number, the shape matters: a crescent-shaped tear, an L-shaped or reverse-L tear with a longitudinal component, and a tear that splits the tendon into layers each behave differently when the surgeon comes to close them, and each has a corresponding repair configuration. The tendon is also examined for delamination, thinning and the state of its edges, since sutures hold poorly in poor tissue.
Retraction and muscle quality: the numbers that predict the outcome
Two further measurements explain why the same tear size can lead to very different outcomes in different patients, and why timing is part of the diagnosis rather than a separate question.
Retraction describes how far the torn tendon end has migrated from the footprint it should occupy on the humerus. It is graded from 1 to 3: near the footprint, at the level of the humeral head, or retracted down to the level of the glenoid. Retraction is not the same as tear size — a moderate tear may have barely moved, and a tear of similar length may have retracted far — and it directly determines the tension under which a repair would have to be sewn.
Fatty infiltration describes how much of the muscle belly has been replaced by fat, graded 0 to 4 on CT or MRI according to a classification in wide use. This is the measurement that expresses what time does to an untreated tear. Muscle replaced by fat does not convert back to muscle after the tendon is reattached, so an advanced grade predicts that the shoulder will not regain full force even if the repair is technically successful. Together, retraction and fatty infiltration are what allow a clinician to say, honestly, that a tear is repairable — and separately, how much function the repair is likely to restore.
What a useful report contains
A report that a patient can act on should answer six questions in plain terms: is the tear partial or full-thickness; how large is it, in centimetres; how far has the tendon retracted; how much fat has entered the muscle; is the long head of biceps or the labrum involved; and has the humeral head begun to rise within the joint. If the mechanism was a fall or a sudden pull, the report should also say so, because that changes how the tear is treated.
Those numbers are what make the next conversation a comparison of real options rather than a choice between an operation and a wait. They are also what a second opinion can work from: a shoulder specialist with the imaging and these measurements in front of them can say whether this tear is one that should be repaired, one that should be rehabilitated first, or one for which reconstruction or replacement is the more honest recommendation — which is precisely the question a written second opinion is meant to answer.