Osteoporotic Vertebral Fracture Diagnosis
Osteoporotic Vertebral Fracture Diagnosis
Confirming a vertebral fracture is straightforward. Confirming that a particular fractured vertebra is the reason for today's pain, and that it is recent enough for the treatments designed for fresh fractures to apply, is not — and that is where the assessment earns its keep. Three questions are answered in order: is there a fracture, how old is it, and is bone loss the whole explanation.
What the examination adds
A fracture is visible on an image, which makes it tempting to treat the image as the diagnosis. It is not: the examination establishes whether the level shown is the level responsible.
Localising the level, and looking at posture
Firm pressure or a gentle tap over the spinous processes, moving one level at a time, often reproduces the pain at the fractured level and leaves the others quiet. Measured standing height, the gap between the back of the head and a wall, and the shape of the upper back describe the cumulative effect of previous fractures. Watching the patient turn over and stand up is informative in the way the history is.
Neurology, and the search for a cause
Power, sensation, reflexes and perineal sensation establish whether the cord or a nerve root is involved, which changes the plan from a pain procedure to a decompression. A general examination looks for signs of the conditions that mimic osteoporosis — weight loss, fever, breast or prostate or lung disease, thyroid disease, and steroid use. Bruising patterns and the recollection of falls feed the falls assessment the bone plan depends on.
Two negative findings are worth acting on. If the examination localises the pain somewhere other than the fractured level, the fracture may be incidental and another source should be pursued before any procedure is discussed — a hip or a sacrum in particular, because both are common sites of a second fragility fracture. And if the pain is constant and night-time rather than positional, the imaging should be read specifically for infection and malignancy.
The lateral radiograph is the baseline
Vertebral fractures are found on the side view, not the front view. A frontal film superimposes the vertebral bodies on each other and on the ribs and bowel gas, and a loss of height in the front of a vertebral body is effectively invisible. This single technical point accounts for a large share of fractures that are present but unreported.
The reading itself is comparative rather than absolute. Each vertebral body is judged against the levels above and below it and against the expected shape at that level, because the normal appearance changes between the thoracic and lumbar spine. Films of the whole thoracolumbar spine, taken standing where possible, allow that comparison; serial films taken years apart are the most valuable of all, since height loss between two studies is unambiguous evidence that something is happening.
A practical consequence: if the films you have were taken lying down, or cover only part of the thoracolumbar spine, that is worth stating when your records are sent for review.
Grading the shape, and what the grade is for
Vertebral shape is graded systematically so that different observers, and the same observer at different times, describe the same vertebra in the same way. The commonly used scheme classifies each level from apparently normal to severely deformed, using the reduction in height of the anterior, middle and posterior parts of the body.
The purpose of the grade is comparison, not severity scoring in the sense patients expect. It allows a film taken this year to be compared with one taken five years ago, and lets a report from another hospital be interpreted consistently. It does not measure pain, does not distinguish a fresh fracture from an old one, and does not by itself say whether anything should be done.
Because the shape is not the whole story, the grade is always read alongside two other facts: whether the fracture involves the middle column and the back wall, and whether the patient's pain localises to that level. A grade of deformity that does not match the pain is a reason to keep looking rather than a reason to proceed.
What MRI answers, and why it dates the fracture
MRI is the test that establishes how recent a fracture is. While a vertebral body is healing, the bone marrow inside it contains fluid and shows increased signal on sequences that are sensitive to water; once the fracture has healed, that signal returns to normal. This bright signal is the imaging signature of an active fracture — the finding that separates a recent injury from an old deformity.
MRI answers three further questions at the same time. It shows whether the cord or the nerve roots are compressed, and at which level. It shows the state of the discs and the alignment of the spine, which matter if more than one level is being considered. And it helps separate causes: a vertebral body destroyed by tumour or infection looks different in the marrow, and is often what prompts the further tests that make the diagnosis.
Its limitations should be understood as well. The signal change of a healing fracture fades over months rather than weeks, so a fracture several months old may still look active, and the history remains part of the dating. Metalwork, pacemakers and claustrophobia make MRI impossible for some patients; the alternatives are a CT read for the back wall and for bone destruction, and a bone scan.
Measuring bone health
A fragility fracture is not only an injury; it is the result of a test the skeleton has already taken and failed. Measuring bone health is therefore part of the assessment rather than a separate referral.
- Bone density measurement. A DXA scan of the spine and hip quantifies bone mineral density and provides the T-score used for diagnosis and monitoring. Many people who fracture have a T-score in the osteopenic range rather than the osteoporotic range, so a borderline result does not cancel the significance of a fracture that has already happened.
- Laboratory tests. Calcium, phosphate, vitamin D, thyroid function, parathyroid hormone and markers of bone turnover identify the contributors that can be corrected and the conditions that require a different treatment altogether — including hyperparathyroidism, vitamin D deficiency, malabsorption and myeloma.
- Fracture risk and falls assessment. A risk calculation combining age, previous fracture, steroid use and other clinical factors gives a fuller estimate of the chance of the next fracture than bone density alone, and it is what treatment thresholds are based on.
What to send, and what the assessment should conclude
Because the plan depends on the age of the fracture and on the state of the back wall, a review is only as good as the material sent. For this condition the correct views matter more than the number of images.
- Lateral radiographs of the thoracolumbar spine, with their dates. If they were taken lying down or cover only part of the region, say so — repeating them properly is usually the most useful thing to arrange before travelling.
- MRI images, not only the report, if any have been done; and any CT, since the back wall is assessed from it.
- Bone density results and blood tests, including vitamin D and parathyroid hormone where available, with the medication list — steroids, anticoagulants and sedatives in particular.
- A short description of the symptoms: when the pain began, what makes it worse, whether lying flat relieves it, and any change in height.
The assessment should finish with something more specific than an impression. Four outcomes are possible: that the fracture is healed and no local intervention is indicated, with bone treatment going ahead; that it is fresh and the pain is severe enough for cementing to be considered; that the back wall is broken or the nerves compressed, and decompression with stabilisation is required; or that the cause is not osteoporosis, in which case the priority is to establish what it is.