Melanoma Prevention
Melanoma Prevention
Prevention in melanoma has two halves, and mixing them up is why advice on the subject often sounds confusing. For the melanomas related to sunlight it means reducing ultraviolet exposure, and the evidence is clearest for daily sunscreen, protective clothing and not using sunbeds. For the melanomas that arise on the sole, under a nail or on a mucosal surface, sunlight plays no part and the only effective measure is knowing what those sites normally look like. After treatment, both halves apply, together with a surveillance schedule.
Sun protection: what follows the evidence
The recommendations for sun protection are not a matter of opinion, and it is worth knowing which of them carry the strongest support, because that is what determines how much effort each deserves:
- Daily sunscreen on exposed skin has the best evidence — a randomised trial in adults who used it every day found fewer melanomas than in those who used it as they wished; use at least SPF 30, apply enough, and reapply after swimming, sweating or a few hours outdoors.
- Covering up is more reliable than any cream — a long-sleeved shirt, trousers, a wide-brimmed hat and sunglasses do not need reapplying and do not miss spots.
- Shade at the middle of the day is the simplest measure, since ultraviolet intensity peaks around midday and is higher at altitude and closer to the equator.
- Sunbeds and sunlamps should not be used at all — they deliver the same agent that causes melanoma in a setting that feels controlled.
- Sunburn is a signal rather than an accident, and what follows from it is a change of plan for the next occasion; protection continues to matter at every age and after a diagnosis.
Vitamin D is often raised as a reason to seek sun deliberately, and the practical answer is that it can be maintained through diet and supplements without ultraviolet exposure. Where a deficiency is found it is treated as a deficiency, with a supplement and a blood test to confirm the response.
Skin checks: doing them in a way that works
A skin check is only useful if it would detect a change, and the methods that work rest on comparison rather than on memorising criteria. They take a few minutes a month:
- Look for the mole that is different from the others — the ugly duckling sign; a melanoma is usually the odd one rather than the largest, and this needs no list of criteria.
- Photographs turn memory into evidence — whole-body views and close views of unusual moles, with a scale in the frame, make the next comparison factual.
- Examine the places that are not in the mirror — the back and the scalp, where a partner or a hairdresser can help, and the soles, between the toes, the nails and the inside of the mouth, which are checked deliberately.
- Set the interval rather than waiting for a reason — monthly self-examination for most people, with periodic examination by a clinician with a dermatoscope for those at higher risk, and the interval written down.
There is no population screening programme, and why
Melanoma is not subject to a national screening programme of the kind that exists for breast, cervical or bowel cancer, and the reason is more useful than the fact:
- The test would be a skin examination, and its value depends on who performs it — a whole-population programme would mean examining very large numbers of people with few risk factors, in whom the chance of finding a melanoma is low, and it would need a workforce trained in dermatoscopy.
- Evidence that a general programme would reduce deaths is not established at that scale, which is why no country has introduced one.
- What exists instead is targeted examination of people at higher risk, which does have support: many or atypical moles, a previous melanoma, a family history, or fair skin with a history of sunburn.
- Most melanomas are detected because someone noticed a change, so self-examination at home is the mechanism that finds thin melanomas rather than a second-best option.
After a melanoma: a second melanoma, and the skin that remains
Someone who has had a melanoma is at higher risk of developing another than a person who has never had one, and this is the main reason surveillance continues for years:
- The skin that produced the first melanoma is still the same skin — the characteristics have not changed and the exposure has already happened, so protection from this point reduces further damage and remains worthwhile at any age.
- The skin examination is universal while imaging follows the stage — everyone continues with skin checks, node areas are examined, and imaging is added for melanomas at higher risk of having spread.
- Where the melanoma was not sun-related the emphasis shifts — for acral and mucosal melanoma the soles, nails and mouth are examined deliberately, and for uveal melanoma a dilated retinal examination at an interval set by the ophthalmologist.
- Know what your own normal looks like, then a change found at home is found with time to spare, and the appointment that follows is short.
What prevention and surveillance cannot do
A clear statement of the limits is more useful than an optimistic one, because it is what makes the plan reliable:
- Reducing risk is not removing it — sunscreen, covering up and avoiding sunbeds lower the chance of the sun-related types, and a melanoma can still occur in someone who has always been careful.
- Protection now does not erase earlier exposure, which is why surveillance continues to matter even after habits change completely.
- Sun protection does nothing against acral, mucosal or eye melanoma, where detection is the only measure available.
- Removing benign moles is not prevention, and there is no evidence that it reduces risk or removes the need for surveillance.
- No supplement, diet or blood test prevents or detects melanoma, and a normal examination does not guarantee the future — which is why it is repeated at intervals.
A short plan that can actually be followed
Prevention advice becomes real when it is written down and specific. Six items cover it:
- Sunscreen every morning on exposed skin — face, ears, neck and hands, at least SPF 30, reapplied when outdoors for long, kept next to the toothpaste so it happens without a decision.
- A shirt, a hat and shade for long periods outdoors, and no sunbeds or sunlamps at all.
- A skin check once a month with a partner or a mirror for the back and scalp, looking for the lesion that is different from the others, and examining the soles, the nails and the mouth deliberately.
- A photograph set taken now, with close views of any unusual moles and a scale in the frame, stored somewhere you will find it.
- A written surveillance interval — who examines your skin, how often, whether photographs or dermoscopy are used, and whether node examination or imaging is part of it.
- A rule for getting in touch — a change in a mole, a new lump in a node area, or a symptom that persists without an innocent explanation.