FOSUN HEALTH Logo

Lumbar Spinal Stenosis Diagnosis

catalogue

Lumbar Spinal Stenosis Diagnosis

Lumbar Spinal Stenosis Diagnosis

Diagnosing stenosis is mostly a matter of putting three things together: how far you can walk and what relieves it, what the neurological examination shows, and what the images show about where the canal is narrow. The third is the one patients arrive with; the first two are the ones that decide what should be done.

Examination: what is tested, and why it is often normal

Patients are frequently surprised that the examination can be unremarkable when walking is so limited, and it is worth explaining why in advance. In a herniated disc one nerve root is compressed abruptly and the examination captures it: a reflex is missing, a strip of skin is numb, a foot is weak. In stenosis the compression is slow and distributed, the nerves adapt, an examination performed lying down relieves the position that causes the problem, and what remains is often a normal set of findings.

For that reason the examination here is broader than a nerve-by-nerve check. Power, sensation and reflexes are tested and any asymmetry noted, since loss of power is unusual and changes the urgency. Nerve tension tests are included, and straight leg raise is usually negative in stenosis — in contrast to a disc herniation, where it is typically positive — so a negative test is informative rather than reassuring on its own. Gait and balance are observed, including whether the patient leans forward and whether unsteadiness is present. A vascular review is routine rather than optional, because arterial disease is common in the same age group, and hip and knee assessment matters because joint disease can be the dominant reason for a reduced distance. The examination is repeated upright where the patient tolerates it, since that is the posture in which symptoms appear.

Measuring the walking distance

Because walking distance is the measurement that treatment decisions rest on, it is worth obtaining properly rather than as an impression.

The clinical history, taken precisely

How far can you walk on the flat before the legs complain? How long must you sit or bend before you can continue? Is that distance the same each day? Has it changed in the last six months, and roughly by how much? These four answers describe the condition better than any single number on a report, and they are recorded at each visit so that the trend is visible.

The bicycle test

Where the history is ambiguous, the patient is asked about cycling. Being able to cycle substantially further than they can walk indicates a positional, mechanical cause and supports stenosis; being equally limited, or worse, suggests the leg arteries should be assessed. The same reasoning applies to walking uphill, which is often easier in stenosis and harder in arterial disease.

Formal treadmill testing exists and is used in research, but it is not required for the diagnosis. What matters is that the number is recorded consistently and repeated, because a distance holding steady and one falling by a hundred metres a month call for different plans.

What MRI shows, and what it cannot

MRI of the lumbar spine is the imaging test of choice. It shows which levels are narrowed and how, whether the narrowing is central, in the lateral recess or at the foramen, whether a facet synovial cyst is occupying space, whether the ligamentum flavum is thickened, and whether one vertebra has slipped forward. It also provides the descriptive grade radiologists apply to central narrowing, most often a four-point scale in which the mildest grade has fluid visible around the nerves and the most severe has the nerves pressed together with no fluid visible.

Its central limitation is worth stating plainly, because it causes a great deal of confusion. An MRI is taken lying down, with the spine straight, which is the position in which the canal is most open. The symptoms occur standing and walking, in a position that narrows it. The picture you are shown is therefore the most favourable view of your spine, and the narrowing it displays is not the amount present when you had to stop walking. Add the fact that many people with markedly narrowed canals have no symptoms at all, and it becomes clear why the images and the experience so often disagree.

Three practical points follow. Compare like with like, since measurements on a standing radiograph and a supine MRI are not directly comparable. Look for the modifier — a slip, a cyst or a deformity changes the operation far more than a change in the grade of central narrowing. And beware the incidental finding: reports often describe changes at levels that do not fit the symptoms, and treating a level because it looks narrow rather than because it explains the complaint is the most common error in this condition.

Radiographs and the question of instability

Plain flexion and extension radiographs are requested when there is reason to suspect that a level moves abnormally. The question is practical rather than academic: if a segment moves on bending, decompressing it without stabilising it may leave the patient with a different problem, and the operation may need to include a fusion as well. If it does not move, a decompression alone is generally preferred, because it is a smaller operation that preserves the segment.

Signs that raise the question include a degenerative slip seen on MRI, previous surgery at the same level, an asymmetric or rotation-related deformity, and symptoms clearly worsened by a change of position rather than by distance alone. Plain radiographs also show the overall alignment of the spine and confirm that the levels being planned are the ones that are degenerated. CT or CT myelography is used when MRI cannot be performed or when bone detail matters for planning around the facet joints and the foraminal openings; it is not a routine part of the assessment.

Nerve studies: when they are worth doing

Electromyography and nerve conduction studies are not required for typical stenosis and do not show it directly, because stenosis is a mechanical problem and the test measures how nerves conduct. They earn their place in three situations: when a second diagnosis such as diabetic neuropathy or a radiculopathy at another level is likely; when the examination and the images disagree and it matters whether a nerve is genuinely affected; and before an operation when the picture is mixed, so that a level not contributing to the problem is not decompressed. The test involves small needle recordings and mild electrical stimulation. It is uncomfortable rather than painful, and its main value here is exclusion — worth having when the treatment under consideration is an operation.

How the findings become a plan

The diagnosis is complete when three statements can be made with confidence: what the patient cannot do and how that is changing; what the examination shows about nerve function; and which levels are narrow in a way that explains the complaint. When all three agree the plan follows naturally. When they do not, the ambiguity is named rather than resolved by treating the most impressive-looking image.

The decision that follows is usually one of three. Where the limitation is mild or stable with no neurological deficit, the plan is a walking and strengthening programme with review, and the steps that help keep the situation stable are relevant. Where the limitation is real but manageable, a structured trial of non-surgical treatment and possibly an injection is appropriate, with a clear review point. Where walking distance is seriously restricted, is falling, or is accompanied by weakness, decompression is discussed properly — including its limits as well as its benefits.

Because the decision rests on function rather than anatomy, images alone are enough to plan an operation but not enough to decide whether one should happen. If you are sending records for an opinion, the description of your walking distance and what relieves it is the most useful thing you can include, and it is the part most patients leave out.

Frequently Asked Questions

If my MRI does not look bad, how can I be so limited?

Because the images are taken lying down, in the position in which the canal is widest, while the symptoms happen standing and walking, in the position in which it is narrowest. A canal that appears adequate on a supine scan can be considerably tighter when the spine is extended under load. There is also real variation between individuals in how much narrowing produces symptoms: some people have a great deal of it with no complaint, and others are markedly limited by less. That is exactly why the walking history carries as much weight as the scan.

Do I need a standing or weight-bearing MRI?

Not routinely. Studies comparing supine and upright imaging have shown that narrowing can increase in the upright position in some patients, but the technology is not widely available and the diagnostic pathway does not depend on it. In practice, a careful history establishing the positional nature of the symptoms carries much of the same information. If an upright or dynamic study is genuinely needed, it is usually because there is a question about instability, and that is more often answered by flexion and extension radiographs.

What does it mean if my report mentions several levels?

It means the degeneration is widespread, which is very common at this age and does not by itself mean several levels need operating on. The task is to work out which of the narrow levels explain your symptoms — usually by matching the level to the distribution of the numbness or the pattern of the walking limit, sometimes with the help of nerve conduction studies. A carefully planned operation may address one level, two, or occasionally more where each is clearly contributing. Treating every narrow level on a report would be a far larger operation than most patients need.

Should I have a repeat scan if my symptoms have changed?

Usually only if the change is one that would alter the plan — new weakness, a clear change in walking distance, or symptoms that have begun to suggest a different level. Repeating imaging at short intervals rarely adds information, because stenosis changes slowly. What is far more useful is to record the walking distance and the examination findings again, since a shrink in the distance with a stable scan is still a change that matters, and one that images would not capture.

Have your images read against your symptoms, not instead of them

Send us your MRI images with their dates, a description of how far you can walk and what relieves it, and any examination or nerve study findings you have. A spinal surgeon and our international team will return a written opinion setting out which levels explain your symptoms, whether any level looks unstable, and whether the next step should be treatment, an injection or an operation.

Want to see the whole process first? Your full medical journey, step by step →

Book an Appointment Request a Video Consultation

Follow Fosun Health

Apply for an Appointment

Do you have test results*