Hip & Knee Osteoarthritis Diagnosis
Hip & Knee Osteoarthritis Diagnosis
Osteoarthritis is one of the few joint conditions that can usually be diagnosed from the history, the examination and one well-taken film. The workup is therefore short — but each step has to be done properly, because a film taken lying down understates the disease, an ungraded film invites over-reading, and the one diagnosis that must be actively excluded — inflammatory arthritis — changes treatment entirely.
What the examination establishes
The examination does three things the film cannot. First, it tests the structures around the joint: the range of motion — with the hip, internal rotation lost early is the classic finding; with the knee, full extension matters more than flexion because a knee that cannot straighten costs more function than one that cannot fully bend. Second, it tests stability: whether the knee holds against sideways stress, and whether the quadriceps fires reliably on a step. Third, it excludes the neighbours — the spine for thigh and buttock pain, the bursa for outer-hip pain, the pes anserinus for inner-knee pain below the joint line.
The walk is examined too, and it is more informative than it sounds: an antalgic gait (less time on the painful leg), a varus or valgus thrust (the knee bowing outward or inward with each step), and a Trendelenburg lurch at the hip each name a specific mechanical problem. All three influence which surgical option, if any, is discussed.
The standing radiograph — and why lying down will not do
Cartilage does not show on a plain film; what shows is the space it occupies. When the joint is loaded — standing — the worn cartilage is compressed and the space narrows to its true value. The same knee filmed lying down shows a reassuring space that simply reflects unloaded relaxation. Every guideline therefore specifies weight-bearing films for knee osteoarthritis, and both sides filmed for comparison: many knees are asymmetric, and the healthy side is the best control the film contains.
For the hip, a standing pelvic film with both hips serves the same purpose. When realignment or replacement is being planned, a long-leg film from hip to ankle is added, because it shows where the weight actually passes through the knee — the information on which osteotomy and partial-replacement decisions depend.
Kellgren–Lawrence grading in practice
The film is graded on a five-point scale from 0 to 4, combining joint-space narrowing, spur formation, hardening of the bone beneath the cartilage and deformity. The details of the grade matter less than two habits of reading it well. The first is to grade the compartment, not just the knee: a knee can be grade 4 in the medial compartment and grade 1 elsewhere, which is precisely the situation in which partial replacement is discussed. The second is to remember that the grade is a structural description: it correlates imperfectly with pain, and it never, by itself, constitutes an indication for surgery.
The grade earns its place in the record as a common language — between radiologist and surgeon, between visits, between opinions. What it must not become is a verdict handed down on a film belonging to someone who has not yet had the function conversation.
When MRI adds something the film cannot
MRI is not part of the routine osteoarthritis workup, and a normal sequence of care treats that as a feature: the film answers the structural question cheaply, and MRI is reserved for the questions it leaves open. Those questions are specific: a suspected meniscus or ligament tear changing the plan (a repairable tear in an otherwise early joint); avascular necrosis, which can be invisible in the first days on plain film; symptoms far ahead of the film — night pain or locking that grade 1–2 change cannot explain; and pre-operative mapping where the surgeon wants the soft tissues assessed.
The reverse error is worth naming too: MRI performed instead of a proper standing film routinely "diagnoses" meniscal tears and cartilage fraying that are normal for the age and irrelevant to the symptoms — a finding that can start a wrong treatment pathway. Sequence matters: film first, examination second, MRI on indication.
Ruling out the arthritis that behaves differently
The history usually already separates inflammatory arthritis from osteoarthritis — hours of morning stiffness, swelling at rest, several joints involved — but the exclusion is confirmed in the laboratory: ESR and CRP as general inflammation markers, and rheumatoid factor and anti-CCP for rheumatoid arthritis. The reason the exclusion is not optional is practical as much as clinical: inflammatory arthritis is treated systemically, and replacing a joint while the inflammatory disease is active has materially worse prospects than replacing it after control.
Crystals occupy the middle ground: gout and pseudogout can live inside an osteoarthritic joint and explain a flare that behaves worse than the baseline. Where a joint is hot and swollen, aspiration and fluid analysis answer in hours what imaging alone can answer in weeks.
What a complete assessment produces
At the end of a proper workup there should be four statements, and you should expect all four explicitly: the grade (per compartment, per joint, on a standing film); the functional stage (what the joint limits, in your terms rather than a questionnaire's); the exclusions (inflammatory disease out, referred pain out, bursae out); and the reasoning — which portion of the symptoms this joint explains, what the non-operative programme should contain and for how long, and what finding would move the plan to surgery. If a consultation has produced a grade but not the other three, it is not finished.
- Bring the films themselves, not the report alone. A grading can be re-read from the images; it cannot be re-read from a sentence about the images. Standing films, with dates.
- Bring the functional history. Walking distance at which pain stops you, stairs, night pain yes or no, work demands. This is the axis the decision actually runs on.
- Bring what you have already tried, and for how long. A non-operative programme that lasted three weeks has not been tried; one that was genuinely followed for months and failed is decisive information.