Hemifacial Spasm Diagnosis
Hemifacial Spasm Diagnosis
Hemifacial spasm is diagnosed clinically — from the pattern and the examination, not from a scan. That is worth stating at the start, because it is the source of both of the errors that bring people to a second opinion: a diagnosis dismissed because a scan was normal, and a scan ordered that was never going to show anything either way. What the history establishes is the shape of the thing — one eye first, spread downward, one side, present in sleep. What the examination establishes is which muscles are involved and whether anything else is. What imaging establishes, where it is indicated and performed properly, is whether a vessel is lying against the nerve. This page sets out each of those, and what a finished assessment should leave behind in writing.
Three questions, and why they outrank a scan
Three questions are asked first, and together they place the great majority of cases before anything is examined. Which eye did it start in, and how long ago? How far has it spread since? Does it happen in sleep? None requires equipment, and all three can be answered by the person or by someone who has watched them.
They work because the patterns differ on exactly these axes. Hemifacial spasm starts around one eye and spreads downward on that side over months to years, and it continues in sleep. Blepharospasm involves both eyes and stays in them. A tic moves around the face and can be held back. Synkinesis follows a palsy and is triggered by another movement. Benign myokymia stays in one lid and stops. Each of those answers a different one of the three questions, and the combination is usually decisive.
What the questions do not do is establish the cause. They establish which pattern this is, and that is the step that has usually been missing. The cause — a vessel against the nerve — is established by imaging where it is indicated, and the reason the two are kept separate is that one of them is clinical and the other is optional.
The reason this outranks imaging is not that imaging is useless. It is that imaging answers a different question, and for the diagnosis itself it is usually the wrong one. How the pattern is recognised at home is set out on the symptoms page.
What the appointment asks, and why a video helps
The first appointment is largely a history, because the history is the test. What is being assembled is a timeline rather than a story: the age at onset and which eye; the order in which the muscles became involved; whether it has ever been on the other side; whether it continues in sleep; what provokes it and what does not; and what has been tried, including any injection, and what came of it.
A video recorded on a phone during an episode is the single most useful item a person can bring, and it is worth more than a written description. It shows the distribution and the character of the movement, it can be reviewed more than once, and it captures the thing that frequently does not happen in the room. Several seconds in ordinary light is enough; a long clip is not needed.
Two questions are asked that people are frequently surprised by. The first is whether anyone has ever had a facial palsy — Bell's palsy, a palsy after an infection, a weakness after an operation or a dental procedure — because synkinesis after a palsy mimics this condition closely and is managed differently, and the question is asked of a companion as well as of the person. The second is whether anyone has seen it during sleep, which cannot be answered about oneself and is asked of whoever shares the room.
What is also asked is what has already been done: which scans, in what year, and with which sequences, together with the reports, because whether the relevant anatomy was ever displayed is one of the two questions a second opinion most often answers.
The parts of the examination that carry the weight
Five things are done in the room, and each answers a question that no scan answers better.
Which muscles are involved, and in what order. The examiner watches the face at rest and with movement, looking at whether the spasm involves the eye, the cheek, the mouth and the neck in the descending pattern described, and whether the forehead is involved on that side — which is expected, because the nerve supplies the whole of that side, and its absence is informative.
Whether there is weakness between episodes. The face is examined when it is not spasming. Spasm does not leave a deficit behind: a droop or asymmetry that persists at rest is not part of this condition and changes the assessment.
Hearing and the other cranial nerves on that side. Hearing is checked, and the nerves supplying the eyes, the tongue, the throat and the shoulders are examined. This is how the minority of structural causes are found, and it is the part of the examination that a video cannot do.
Whether it can be suppressed. The person is asked to hold the movement back. A tic can often be suppressed for a time, sometimes long enough to get through an appointment; hemifacial spasm cannot, beyond a moment.
The character of the movement. Whether it builds and eases over seconds, or arrives as the same brief stereotyped burst each time — the distinction between spasm and a focal seizure, which sends the assessment down a different path.
Which imaging is used, and on what grounds
Imaging here is indicated rather than routine. Each scan below is used because a specific question has been raised — by the pattern, by the examination, or by a feature on the atypical list — and where no question has been raised, it usually answers nothing.
| Test | The question it answers | When it is not used |
|---|---|---|
| 3.0T MRI with sequences for the nerve and vessels | Whether a vessel is lying against the facial nerve where it leaves the brainstem | Not as a routine head scan with no indication. Without the dedicated sequences it does not display this |
| Magnetic resonance angiography | Whether a vascular loop, an aneurysm or an unusual vessel is part of the picture | Not as an addition to a normal scan with no question behind it |
| Imaging of the cerebellopontine angle | Whether a structural lesion is behind the spasm, where hearing or another cranial nerve is involved | Not routinely. It is ordered where the examination or an atypical feature has raised it |
| Electromyography of the facial muscles | Whether the pattern is synkinesis rather than spasm, where a palsy has preceded it or the picture is unclear | Not needed for a straightforward case. Used where the two cannot be separated clinically |
| Hearing assessment | Whether hearing is measurably reduced on the affected side | Not where there is no history of any change in hearing |
| Electroencephalography and video recording | Whether the movement is a focal seizure, where the character or the stereotypy raises it | Not routinely. Only where the question is genuinely open |
| A review of previous scans and reports | Which sequences were performed, and therefore whether a previous normal result was informative | Not a test. It is frequently the most valuable part of a second opinion |
The discipline that governs the table is a single question asked before anything is ordered: what would be done differently if this came back normal? Where the answer is nothing, it is not ordered and the reason is written down. Where the answer changes the plan, it is ordered within the same programme rather than referred outward, and the result comes back with an interpretation rather than as a report alone. Where treatment begins once the pattern is named is set out on the treatment page.
When no vessel is shown, and what that changes
This is the section people come to a second opinion for, and the answer is narrower than most expect. Imaging is not what makes the diagnosis, so a scan that shows no vessel does not exclude hemifacial spasm. The diagnosis remains clinical, made from the pattern and the examination, and the plan continues on that basis.
What it does change is the second decision rather than the first. Where a vessel has been demonstrated, that is part of what makes an operation a reasonable thing to discuss. Where it has not, the option is not removed — but the conversation is different, and it should be had with the scan in hand rather than around it.
What must be separated here, and is frequently not, is a normal scan from an uninformative scan. A study performed with the dedicated sequences that shows no vessel has answered the question. One performed without them has not asked it, and reporting it as normal while treating the matter as closed is the commonest failure in this condition. Whether the relevant anatomy was ever displayed is knowable from the report, and it is the question worth asking.
Where the picture genuinely is incomplete, the honest statement is that the mechanism has not been demonstrated, that the diagnosis is clinical and stands, and that the plan is a review at a defined interval. That is a real plan with a real endpoint, and it is worth more than another scan ordered to fill the silence.
What a finished assessment leaves behind in writing
An assessment is not finished when the appointment ends. What should exist afterwards is a written statement of five things, and a person is entitled to ask for each of them.
First, the name of the pattern — hemifacial spasm, or one of the five it is mistaken for, and where the two are not separable, that said plainly rather than left as an impression. Second, what was excluded and how, including whether the imaging performed was the imaging that could have shown the vessels. Third, whether any atypical feature is present, with the specific item named. Fourth, the first step, which is sometimes an explanation and nothing more, and is none the less a plan for being written down. Fifth, what would make the plan change — the features that should bring the person back sooner rather than at the next convenient date.
Alongside it, a review at a defined interval. Where an injection is the plan, that means at a point in its cycle where the effect can be judged rather than at the next available appointment. Where an operation is being discussed, it means with the imaging in hand and the risks written out rather than summarised.
A written opinion is returned within 48 hours of complete records arriving, and for a records-only review that means from the point the file is complete rather than from the point it is first sent. What treatment looks like once the pattern is named is set out on the treatment page.