Carotid & Intracranial Stenosis Diagnosis
Carotid & Intracranial Stenosis Diagnosis
The number in a stenosis report is a ratio, and a ratio has a denominator. Two long-standing methods for measuring carotid stenosis use different denominators — one compares the narrowest point with the vessel beyond it, the other with what the vessel would have been at that point — and the same artery therefore comes out with a higher percentage by one than by the other. This is not pedantry. Thresholds for treatment were established using one of these methods, and a number measured the other way and read against that threshold will put a patient on the wrong side of it.
Carotid duplex ultrasound
Ultrasound is usually the study that finds a carotid narrowing and usually the study that follows it. It does not measure the channel directly; it measures how fast the blood is moving through it, because the same volume forced through a narrower tube has to go faster. From the peak velocities, and from the ratio between the velocity at the narrowing and the velocity just beyond it, the degree is derived.
Two consequences follow. The percentage it produces is derived from velocities rather than drawn from images, so it is influenced by the angle of the probe, by the vessel's course, and by what is happening upstream — a severe narrowing higher up, or an occlusion on the other side, changes the velocities on this one. And it is operator-dependent, which is why a change between two ultrasound reports is more convincing when both were done in the same laboratory.
Its strengths are the ones that matter for follow-up: no radiation, no contrast, quick, repeatable, and cheap enough to do again. It visualises the plaque as well as the flow, and it can say whether a lesion is calcified, which is useful later if a procedure is planned.
CT angiography and MR angiography
Both show the lumen as an image rather than inferring it from velocity, and both are read for the narrowing and for what surrounds it. CT angiography shows calcification well and is fast, which is why it is the study used when an answer is needed in minutes; it involves iodine contrast and radiation, which matters in a patient with kidney disease. MR angiography involves no radiation, and the MRI performed at the same time shows the brain — which is the single most valuable addition, because it answers whether tissue has already been lost.
Both have characteristic ways of being wrong in the same direction. Calcified plaque can make a narrowing look worse on CT than it is, because the calcium is dense and can be read as occupying the channel. MR angiography can overestimate a narrowing where flow is turbulent and the signal drops out, and it is less reliable for the small posterior circulation vessels. Neither substitutes for catheter angiography when intervention is the question, and both are entirely adequate when it is not.
Which one a patient should have depends on whether the brain imaging has been done: if the MRI of the brain has not been performed, that is the gap worth filling first.
Catheter angiography
Digital subtraction angiography remains the reference study. Contrast is injected through a catheter and the vessels are imaged as they fill in sequence, which is a different kind of information from a static picture: it shows direction of flow, how quickly a territory fills, and where the blood is coming from when a route is blocked. It is the study on which the collateral circulation is assessed, and the one used when a procedure is being planned.
It carries a small but real risk — of stroke, of injury to the artery at the puncture site, of a reaction to contrast, and of kidney injury — which is why it is not performed simply to confirm what a good CT angiogram has already shown. It is performed by the team who would carry out the intervention, because the images are the plan rather than a report that leads to one.
One thing it settles better than anything else is whether a narrowing is one lesion or several in series. Two moderate narrowings one after the other are not the same as one moderate narrowing.
What the plaque is, not only how much it narrows
Two narrowings measured at the same percentage are not the same finding. What differs between them is composition, and the features that have been described as carrying more risk are ulceration of the surface, haemorrhage inside the plaque, and a large lipid-rich core under a thin cap. A smooth, heavily calcified plaque that narrows the channel substantially is a different lesion from a soft, irregular one that narrows it less.
This is why imaging of the plaque itself belongs in a complete workup rather than being an addition to it. It is obtained from the CT or MR angiogram most patients have already had, from dedicated plaque MRI where it is available, and to a degree from ultrasound, which describes whether a lesion is uniform or irregular and whether it is calcified.
It is also the reason a report that gives only a percentage is not enough to act on. The percentage describes the channel. The plaque describes the lesion. The decision is made on both, together with whether the patient has had a symptom from it.
What it has cost in flow
Perfusion imaging measures a different thing from the whole rest of the workup. Rather than how many millimetres the channel is, it measures how much blood the tissue downstream is actually receiving, and how close to the limit it is running. The patterns described include a prolongation of the time contrast takes to arrive, a reduction in the volume of blood in the tissue, and, where the situation is advanced, a reduction in the flow itself.
The reason it earns its place is that degree and consequence do not track each other. A severe narrowing with a well-developed collateral supply may leave the tissue adequately perfused, and a moderate narrowing with poor collaterals and a border-zone pattern of injury on the MRI has already cost the patient something. The perfusion study is what separates those two, and it is the study that answers whether the narrowing is haemodynamically significant rather than merely anatomically present.
It is also the study most often absent, for a straightforward reason: the workup was ordered to look at the neck, and looking at the neck does not produce it. Where a decision is difficult, or where a patient has been told to wait, this is the investigation most likely to change the answer.
What a complete report answers
A report worth acting on answers six questions, and it is reasonable to ask for all six before a decision is made.
Where the narrowing is — carotid bifurcation, intracranial carotid, middle cerebral artery, or the posterior circulation. How much, and by which method, because the number cannot be read against a threshold without it. What the plaque is like, smooth or ulcerated. Whether the patient has had a symptom from it, and in which territory. Whether tissue has already been lost downstream, which comes from imaging of the brain rather than of the vessel. And what the other vessels are doing, on the other side and in series.
Where the answer to the second is missing a method, the correct response is not to guess which one was used but to ask. Where the fifth is missing entirely, the missing study is an MRI of the brain, and it is worth having before rather than after a decision. And where the fourth is unclear — a referral letter that says stroke and stenosis without saying which caused which — that is the question to settle first, because everything after it depends on the answer.