Avascular Necrosis of the Femoral Head Diagnosis
Avascular Necrosis of the Femoral Head Diagnosis
The diagnosis of avascular necrosis is an imaging diagnosis with a short clinical preamble: the examination decides whether the symptoms belong to the hip joint, and the images decide whether the bone is dead, at what stage, how large the affected segment is, and what the other hip is doing. Getting the sequence right is not a matter of thoroughness but of timing — the stage at the moment of diagnosis is the single most useful fact in the whole assessment, and the examinations are chosen with that in mind.
The examination: does this pain belong to the hip joint?
The examination has one job before any imaging is ordered: to establish that the symptoms come from the hip joint rather than from the spine, the bursa over the trochanter, or the muscles around it. Three findings carry most of the weight. Internal rotation, tested with the hip both flexed and straight, is the earliest movement to be lost and the most specific. End-range pain — pain at the limit of flexion, abduction or rotation rather than through the middle of the range — points to the joint itself. And a limp with a leg that rests turned outward is a late but unmistakable sign of a hip that no longer holds its shape.
Two additional tests help when the picture is ambiguous. The FABER test — flexion, abduction and external rotation, the "figure of four" position — loads the hip and the sacroiliac region in a way that separates them. A resisted straight-leg raise stresses the hip joint from the front and is positive in hip disease but not in referred pain from the spine. Neither test makes the diagnosis; together with the history they decide whether the next image is of the hip, the lumbar spine, or both.
What the examination deliberately does not do is stage the disease. An early hip can be severely painful, while a hip whose surface has already collapsed can be comparatively comfortable; and how much rotation is preserved reflects the muscles around the hip and the patient's tolerance at least as much as it reflects the bone. These findings are recorded as a baseline — the numbers that later visits are compared against — while the stage is read from the imaging.
The radiograph: what it shows, and when it is normal
A radiograph of the pelvis with a lateral view of the affected hip is part of every assessment, because it stages the disease and because it shows the shape of the socket and the quality of the bone that any operation will have to work with. Its limitation is equally important: in the earliest stage the film is genuinely normal, and a normal radiograph in a symptomatic hip with a risk factor is not evidence that the hip is healthy.
As the disease progresses, four things appear in sequence. First sclerosis — an area of bone that looks denser, sometimes with small cysts. Then the crescent sign — a thin curved dark line just under the joint surface, which is the subchondral crack that marks the structure beginning to give way. Then flattening of the surface, which is the collapse itself. Finally narrowing of the joint space with sclerosis of the socket, the secondary arthritis of the whole joint. The film is also the basis for measuring the depth of depression, and for showing whether the shape has changed since the last one.
MRI: the examination that makes the diagnosis
MRI is the examination on which the diagnosis rests, and it is the reason a hip can be treated before it collapses. It shows the boundary between living and dead bone long before the radiograph changes, and it characterises the lesion in three dimensions. Two appearances are characteristic. On T1-weighted images there is a serpiginous line of low signal — a wavy, well-defined border outlining the affected segment, often described as geographical. On T2-weighted images the double-line sign appears: an outer low-signal rim with a high-signal band inside it, representing the reactive tissue at the interface between dead and living bone. The lesion usually sits in the anterosuperior part of the head, which is the region that carries load.
Three practical consequences follow. The first is that MRI is arranged early in anyone with a compatible history and a risk factor, rather than after a trial of treatment. The second is that both hips are imaged in the systemic forms of the disease, because the opposite hip is often involved and often earlier. The third is that MRI does not replace staging: it detects and measures the lesion, while the stage — especially whether collapse has begun — is read on the radiograph and, when the depth of depression matters, on CT. A patient whose MRI shows the disease but whose film has not been properly reviewed has an incomplete assessment.
Two other examinations need to be placed correctly. A bone scan is not a screening tool for this disease: it is less sensitive than MRI in the early stage, it does not characterise the lesion, and it is not used to decide treatment. CT is used for two specific questions — measuring the depth of depression where a plain film is hard to judge, and assessing bone stock and pelvic anatomy when planning a complex or revision replacement.
Reading the stage: ARCO and Ficat, and why both are quoted
Two systems are used side by side, and reports often give both. Ficat and Arlet has four stages and is compact and familiar: stage I with a normal film and abnormal MRI, stage II with sclerosis and cysts but a spherical head, stage III with the crescent sign, stage IV with collapse and secondary arthritis. ARCO subdivides the same sequence further: stage 0 for a hip in a high-risk patient with normal imaging, stages 1 and 2 as above, stage 3 divided into 3A (depression under 2 mm) and 3B (2 mm or more), and stage 4 with arthritis of the whole joint. The ARCO subdivision of stage 3 exists because the depth of depression changes what is still worth attempting.
What the systems share, and what matters more than either label, is the separation into pre-collapse and post-collapse. Every classification puts this line in the middle, and every treatment decision sits on one side of it or the other. Joint-preserving operations are designed for the pre-collapse hip and lose their reliability as the surface flattens; replacement is designed for the hip whose surface has already failed. A report that gives a stage number without saying whether the surface has flattened has not answered the question the surgeon is asking.
Two further reminders. A stage does not predict pain: the functional axis — how far you can walk, whether sleep is interrupted, how much rotation has been lost — is recorded on its own line, and it is what sets the timing. Nor does a stage predict the future on its own: the same stage can behave differently in two patients, which is why the next section matters as much as this one.
Size and position: the measurement that changes the advice
Beneath the stage number sit two measurements that do much of the work in deciding what to offer: how much of the femoral head is involved and where the affected segment sits. A lesion confined to the inner part of the head, away from the weight-bearing surface, has a far better natural history than one of the same stage occupying the outer and upper region where the body's load passes through. Size is commonly expressed as a proportion of the head's cross-sectional area or using an angular measure from the centre of the head; position is described by the region involved.
These measurements are why two patients with "stage 2 avascular necrosis" may be advised differently. A small lesion in a favourable position in a patient with no ongoing exposure to the cause may be observed with imaging at intervals, or treated with a limited operation. A large lesion in the weight-bearing region, particularly in a patient who will need further steroid treatment, is a hip whose collapse is often expected — and the discussion shifts to planning an operation that will still work when it happens. The measurement also sets expectations for preservation surgery: what a decompression or a graft can reasonably achieve depends on what is being asked of it.
What a completed assessment should answer
Four statements turn imaging into a plan, and a patient is entitled to all four in writing.
- The diagnosis, stated plainly — avascular necrosis of the femoral head, with the cause if one has been identified, and with the note that this is a disease of blood supply rather than of wear.
- The stage of each hip — using ARCO or Ficat, with the explicit statement of whether the joint surface has collapsed, and with the size and position of the lesion.
- The other hip, addressed — imaged, staged, and either found normal or included in the plan.
- The reasoning and the next interval — why preservation is or is not still worth attempting, what the alternatives are, and when the next set of images is due if the decision is to watch rather than to operate.
If the assessment has answered fewer than four, the missing piece is usually the one that changes the decision. A stage without a statement about collapse, or a single hip assessed without the other, is an incomplete answer rather than a cautious one — and in a disease that moves in months, the interval spent finding out is part of the treatment.