ALS (Motor Neuron Disease) Symptoms
ALS (Motor Neuron Disease) Symptoms
ALS usually announces itself as one small thing that has become impossible: a button that cannot be done up, a key that will not turn, a foot that catches on flat ground, or a voice that others say has changed. It is not painful, it does not usually begin with numbness, and it does not stay where it started. This page sets out what the first signs look like, how they spread, what the disease characteristically leaves alone, and why breathing and swallowing are watched from the beginning rather than after something goes wrong.
The first signs — a lost ability, not a pain
The thing people notice is almost never a sensation. It is a task. The hand will not do up a shirt button, the grip on a pen tires after a line, the key sticks in the lock and the wrist cannot finish turning, the foot catches on a carpet edge that was never a problem, or a voice has begun to sound slightly nasal and other people ask about it first. That framing — a lost ability rather than a new feeling — is characteristic, and it is worth saying plainly because people wait for pain or numbness and, not finding it, conclude nothing is wrong.
| Starting point | What the person notices | What it is often mistaken for |
|---|---|---|
| Hand and thumb | Buttons, keys, jar lids, handwriting that deteriorates, dropping things; the flesh between thumb and index finger looks flatter | A trapped nerve, carpal tunnel syndrome, or getting older |
| Arm and shoulder | Lifting overhead becomes hard, the arm tires quickly, the shoulder blade wings | A rotator cuff problem or a neck problem |
| Foot and leg | Foot drop, tripping, a shoe that scuffs, a leg that feels heavy and stiff, cramps in the calf | A back problem, a circulation problem, or clumsiness |
| Speech and swallowing | Slurred or nasal speech that tires, a tongue that feels thick, choking on liquids, food that takes longer to get down | Dental work, a throat infection, or a stroke — and it is worth excluding a stroke promptly |
| Breathing | Breathlessness lying flat, waking at night, morning headache, daytime sleepiness, losing the thread in conversation | Asthma, being unfit, or poor sleep — and wrongly so, because this one is urgent |
One more feature deserves its own line, because it is the most common reason people arrive at this page: twitching. Visible twitching under the skin — fasciculation — is common in people with no neurological disease, and its significance depends entirely on what accompanies it. Twitching with normal strength and normal muscle bulk is usually benign; twitching alongside progressive weakness and thinning is not.
How the weakness spreads
The defining behaviour of ALS is spread. Weakness begins in one region and, over months, appears in others — and the documentation of that spread is part of the diagnosis rather than merely a consequence of it.
The common route is local first and then regional: a hand that began alone is joined by the other hand, or by the same arm proximally, and then by the leg; or speech and swallowing come first and are followed by the arms and then the legs. What begins as asymmetric typically becomes more symmetric as it goes. Alongside the weakness, the limb changes character: it becomes stiff and slow as well as weak, cramps appear, and the reflexes become brisk. These are the upper motor neuron features arriving alongside the lower motor neuron ones, and together they make the picture recognisable.
What the spread means practically is that the plan has to be made in advance rather than in response. A person whose hands are affected will need their legs assessed for what is coming; a person with foot drop will need their hands and their speech assessed; and every person with any of these needs their breathing measured, because the breathing muscles are part of the same disease whether or not they have announced themselves.
What ALS leaves alone
What a disease does not do is often as useful as what it does, and in ALS the pattern of sparing is one of the things that separates it from the conditions most often confused with it.
| Function | What is typical in ALS |
|---|---|
| Sensation — touch, pain, temperature, vibration | Usually preserved throughout. Persistent numbness or tingling points towards another diagnosis |
| Eye movement | Typically spared, including late in the disease. This is one reason eye-gaze communication devices remain available when speech and hands are gone |
| Bladder and bowel control | Usually preserved. Loss of control suggests a different problem — a spinal cord lesion, for instance |
| Thinking and memory | Preserved in most people. A minority develop frontotemporal change affecting behaviour, judgement and word-finding |
| The sense of being in pain from the nerve loss itself | Pain is not a feature of the weakness. Pain that occurs comes from joints, posture, cramps and stiffness, and is treatable |
There is an important consequence of the sparing, and it is the practical reason this section exists. Because eye movement is typically preserved and because communication devices driven by eye gaze exist, a person can remain able to communicate long after speech and hand function have gone. That possibility should be raised early, while the person can still make the decision about it, rather than discovered late.
Breathing and swallowing — the two to watch
Breathing and swallowing are where the disease does most of its harm, and both are watched from the beginning rather than after symptoms appear, because by the time they are obvious the window for the easier decision has often closed.
| Signal | What it means, and what to do |
|---|---|
| Breathlessness lying flat | The diaphragm is struggling when it is asked to work against the abdomen. It is measured, not waited out |
| Waking at night, unrefreshing sleep | Breathing during sleep is under-supported. This is the point at which nocturnal support usually begins |
| Morning headache and daytime sleepiness | Carbon dioxide retained overnight. A clear indication to measure breathing rather than to try another pillow |
| Weak cough, chest infections | Secretions are not being cleared. Cough-assistance techniques and devices are introduced |
| Choking on liquids, food taking longer | Swallowing is becoming unsafe. A formal swallowing assessment is arranged, and the texture of food and drink is changed on advice rather than by guesswork |
| Weight falling, and meals becoming tiring | The effort of eating has exceeded the reward. This is the point at which a feeding tube is discussed, deliberately before it is urgent |
Both of these are measurable, and that is the point. Breathing function is measured with simple tests at the clinic, and swallowing is assessed by a speech and language therapist with a formal examination. Neither requires the person to feel unwell first — and the living-with-ALS page sets out the schedule on which they are repeated.
What else looks like this
ALS is diagnosed partly by excluding conditions that imitate it, and several of those are treatable. This is the reason a thorough assessment is worth having even when the diagnosis seems clear.
| Condition | What separates it |
|---|---|
| Cervical myelopathy with radiculopathy | Both weakness and wasting occur, but sensory change is prominent and the level follows the spine; it is identified on MRI |
| Multifocal motor neuropathy with conduction block | Purely lower motor neuron weakness, often asymmetric and in the hands, with conduction block on nerve conduction studies — and it responds to immunoglobulin treatment |
| Kennedy disease | Slowly progressive bulbar and limb weakness in men, with sensory involvement and endocrine features, confirmed by genetic testing |
| Myasthenia gravis | Weakness that fluctuates through the day and affects the eyes and swallowing; separated by antibodies and by electrophysiology |
| Inclusion body myositis | Weakness with a different distribution — finger flexors and quadriceps — and a muscle enzyme pattern pointing to muscle rather than nerve |
| Metabolic and nutritional mimics | Thyroid disease and vitamin B12 deficiency among them: found on blood tests, and treatable |
The diagnosis page sets out how each of these is excluded, and what the electromyography contributes to the separation.
When to be seen
Progressive weakness that is painless and accompanied by visible wasting should be assessed, and it should not be assessed eventually. A hand that is measurably weaker this month than last, a foot that catches repeatedly, a voice that others have commented on, or muscle that looks thinner than it did — each of these warrants a neurology appointment, and the earlier it happens the more useful the assessment is, because progression is easier to demonstrate than to recall.
Some things do not wait for an appointment. Breathlessness at rest, an inability to lie flat, confusion or drowsiness, a choking episode with breathing difficulty, or a fever with a weak cough — these need urgent assessment, and in the case of acute breathing difficulty, emergency care.
What to bring to that first appointment is worth preparing: when the weakness began, which task failed first, whether anyone else in the family has had ALS or frontotemporal dementia, photographs or measurements if you have them, and every previous report. What to send ahead of an international opinion is set out on the practical questions page.