Heart Failure Causes
Heart Failure Causes
Heart failure is an outcome, and outcomes do not explain themselves. Behind almost every case there is a specific disease doing something to the pump — starving it of blood, loading it with pressure, damaging its muscle, or driving it too fast for too long. Finding out which is not an academic exercise: a cause that can be repaired changes the treatment plan, and a cause that cannot be repaired still changes the order in which the plan is built. This page sets out the main routes, the clue each one leaves, and the small group of contributors that are worth hunting for because they can be corrected.
Heart failure is an outcome, not a cause
Two patients with the same diagnosis, the same ejection fraction and the same breathlessness can need completely different things, because the diagnosis describes the pump's behaviour and says nothing about why it is behaving that way. The reason to name the cause is therefore not tidiness. It decides whether a procedure is on the table, whether a specific drug is indicated, whether a family member should be screened, and whether the plan should be aimed at the arteries, the valves, the muscle or the rhythm.
It also changes the order of work. In a patient whose failure is driven by ongoing ischaemia, restoring blood flow may come before fine-tuning doses. In a patient whose failure followed a viral illness, the plan is largely about time, medicines and rehabilitation. In a patient with an infiltrative disease, the treatment is directed at the infiltrating process itself. Same syndrome, three different clinics.
Each upstream disease has its own guide. Coronary artery disease, valve disease, hypertension, the cardiomyopathies and the rhythm disorders are conditions in their own right, with their own diagnosis and their own treatment, and this cluster deliberately does not reproduce them. This guide describes what happens when the pump is left failing, whichever road led there; where a reader needs the upstream disease, the relevant guide is the one to read.
Coronary disease and previous infarction
Narrowed coronary arteries can weaken the pump in more than one way, and the differences matter because they carry different implications for treatment.
- Scar — an infarction kills a territory of muscle, which is replaced by scar that does not contract. The remaining muscle has to make up for the loss, and the ventricle may enlarge and change shape around the dead segment, a process called remodelling.
- Muscle that is short of blood but not dead — segments that contract poorly because they are under-supplied can recover their function once blood flow is restored, which is why an assessment that shows poor movement in a segment is not the same as one that shows scar.
- Ongoing ischaemia — narrowed arteries that still limit flow under demand keep the muscle under strain, and can also provoke rhythm problems, so they are treated as an active contributor rather than as background history.
This is the cause that offers the most opportunities, because it is one of the few where a procedure can change the pump rather than only the symptoms. It is also the reason the search for coronary disease is built into the assessment of almost every patient with a new diagnosis of heart failure, and the reason the treatment page treats revascularisation as part of heart failure care rather than a separate specialty. Establishing it requires the same work as diagnosing coronary disease on its own: a stress test with imaging, a CT angiogram, or an invasive angiogram, chosen by what the patient's history and fitness make sensible.
Pressure and volume overload
A pump can fail not only because it is damaged but because it has been asked to work against too much resistance, or to move too much volume, for too long. These are the causes that reward being found early, because the load can often be reduced.
| Overload | How it works on the pump | What is looked for |
|---|---|---|
| High blood pressure over years | The ventricle thickens to push against the resistance, becomes stiff, then eventually dilates and weakens | The blood pressure history, the wall thickness on the echocardiogram, and the voltage pattern on the electrocardiogram |
| Aortic stenosis | A narrowed outflow valve forces the ventricle to generate much higher pressures with every beat | The murmur, the valve on the echocardiogram, and the gradient across it; symptoms may appear late, which is why the valve is measured rather than waited on |
| Mitral or aortic regurgitation | Blood leaks backwards with each beat, so the ventricle pumps a volume twice over and dilates | The murmur, the valve on the echocardiogram, and the size of the ventricle — regurgitation can be a cause of dilatation or one of its consequences |
| High-output states | The body demands an unusually large flow — severe anaemia, an overactive thyroid, a shunt or a fistula — and a normal pump can be overwhelmed | The blood count, thyroid function, and the examination; these are the causes most often missed because the heart itself looks unremarkable |
Two distinctions are worth carrying away from this table. The first is that a valve problem can sit on either side of the causal line: a leaky mitral valve can be why the ventricle dilated, or it can be the result of a ventricle that has already dilated, and the two are treated differently. The second is that treating the load is sometimes the whole of the treatment — a patient whose failure is driven by uncontrolled blood pressure has a plan whose centre of gravity is the blood pressure, however many other medicines are also on the list.
Diseases of the muscle itself
When the arteries are open and the valves are competent and the pump is still weak, the muscle is the place to look. This group of causes is the reason cardiac magnetic resonance has become part of heart failure assessment, because several of them leave patterns that imaging can recognise and routine tests cannot.
| Cause | The clue it leaves | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Inherited (familial) cardiomyopathy | A dilated, poorly contracting ventricle in a younger patient, or a family history of heart failure, transplantation or sudden death | It makes screening of first-degree relatives relevant, and it changes how other family members are advised |
| Infiltrative disease — amyloidosis, sarcoidosis, iron overload | Thick walls with a stiff, poorly filling ventricle, distinctive patterns on magnetic resonance, and clues elsewhere in the body | These are treated specifically rather than as generic heart failure, which is why recognising the pattern is worth the effort |
| Myocarditis and inflammatory disease | A recent viral illness or an autoimmune condition, with a rapid onset and often chest discomfort or rhythm disturbance | It shifts the emphasis towards time, anti-inflammatory treatment where appropriate, and rehabilitation rather than towards devices |
| Treatment-related damage — some chemotherapy agents and chest radiotherapy | A history of cancer treatment, sometimes years earlier, with a decline that follows it | It changes how the patient is monitored during any future treatment, and it makes cardiology input part of cancer care |
| Alcohol, thyroid disease and metabolic causes | A history of sustained heavy drinking, thyroid symptoms, or a metabolic disorder found on routine bloods | Several of these are reversible, and improvement after removing the cause can be substantial rather than marginal |
The practical message from this table is that the words "heart failure" are sometimes an intermediate label. A patient whose muscle is weak for an unexplained reason, particularly if they are young or have a relevant family history, is a patient for whom the extra tests are not academic: they are the difference between a general plan and a specific one. Family screening is the other consequence — a diagnosis of inherited cardiomyopathy is information that belongs to relatives as well as to the patient.
Rhythm: cause and consequence
Rhythm problems and heart failure run in both directions, and untangling which is which changes the treatment. A ventricle that is being driven too fast does not have time to fill between beats, so it delivers less blood while working harder — and if that continues for weeks, the pump can weaken even though the muscle itself was never diseased. This is one of the few causes of a weakened pump that can be substantially reversed, which is why a rhythm that has been present for a long time is worth identifying specifically rather than noting in passing.
Atrial fibrillation is the commonest version of this, and it is genuinely bidirectional. It can aggravate heart failure by removing the contribution of an organised atrial contraction and by allowing a fast rate; and a failing heart, with its raised pressures and stretched atria, makes atrial fibrillation more likely to occur and to persist. Bradycardia has the opposite failure mode — too few beats rather than too many — and a slow, irregular rhythm or a long pause is a reason to look at the conduction system rather than at the muscle.
The practical consequence is a question worth asking in every assessment: how fast, how irregular, and for how long. A rate that has been uncontrolled for months is a different proposition from one that became fast last week; and in the right patient, restoring a stable rhythm is a treatment of the heart failure, not a separate problem to be managed alongside it.
The contributors worth hunting for
Some contributors do not cause heart failure on their own, but they make it worse, keep it worse, or hide behind it. They are on this page because finding them is cheap and correcting them changes how the patient feels — and because they are missed when an assessment stops at the phenotype.
- Iron deficiency — common in heart failure, frequently present without anaemia, and treatable; it is looked for with ferritin and transferrin saturation rather than inferred from the haemoglobin.
- Thyroid disease — both an overactive and an underactive thyroid can weaken the pump and disturb the rhythm, and both are correctable.
- Alcohol — the effect on the muscle is dose-related, and the advice in heart failure is usually to stop or to limit strictly; the reason is the muscle rather than the calories.
- Sleep apnoea — repeated drops in oxygen at night load the heart and fragment sleep; it is common in heart failure and is looked for with a sleep study rather than assumed.
- Medicines that hold water or strain the heart — non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, some steroids and certain diabetes medicines can cause fluid retention or worsen the picture; any new medicine deserves the question before it is started.
- Salt and fluid beyond what the plan allows — not a cause of the disease, but the commonest reason a stable patient becomes unstable, and the one contributor entirely in the patient's own hands.
None of these items requires expensive technology to find, and each of them changes something concrete: a dose, a habit, a referral, or a medicine that should not be there. That is the test of whether a contributor belongs on this list — not how interesting it is, but whether finding it changes what happens next.